10 School Rules from the Past That Would Get Teachers Fired Today

Schools used to have some wild rules that, if enforced today, would have teachers packing up their desks before lunchtime.

Sophia Zapanta
March 10, 2025
4 min read

10 School Rules from the Past That Would Get Teachers Fired Today — Robert So on Pexels

Times have changed, and so have school rules—thankfully. Some of the policies from the past were so strict, unfair, or downright dangerous that they’d never fly today. Here are 10 outdated school rules that would likely cost a teacher their job in modern times.

1. Corporal Punishment

Markus Winkler on Pexels

Back in the day, teachers could discipline students by hitting them with paddles, rulers, or even their bare hands. Some schools even had an actual “punishment chair” or designated spanking rooms. While some states technically still allow it, most parents today would call a lawyer before letting a teacher touch their child. A viral video of a teacher doing this now would mean immediate suspension (or worse).

2. Public Humiliation as Discipline

RDNE Stock project on Pexels

Teachers used to make kids wear dunce caps, stand in corners for hours, or even write embarrassing confessions on the board. Students were sometimes forced to hold heavy books as punishment while the class laughed. Today, this would be considered emotional abuse and a fast track to a lawsuit. Public shaming has been replaced with awkward parent-teacher conferences.

3. Forcing Left-Handed Kids to Write with Their Right Hand

RDNE Stock project on Pexels

For decades, left-handed children were forced to “correct” their natural writing hand because left-handedness was considered wrong or even “evil.” Teachers would tie children’s left hands behind their backs or smack them with rulers if they tried to use them. This practice led to stress, poor handwriting, and unnecessary frustration. Nowadays, forcing a child to switch hands would be seen as ridiculous and abusive.

4. Gender-Segregated Classes and Subjects

Philippe WEICKMANN on Pexels

It was once common for girls to take home economics while boys took shop classes, with no option to switch. Some schools even had separate classrooms or stricter dress codes for different genders. Enforcing these outdated gender norms today would result in major backlash. Now, everyone gets the chance to burn toast in home economics or slice their thumb in woodworking—equality!

5. Unsupervised Recess and Playground Hazards

Samuel Adeleke on Pexels

Old-school playgrounds were a survival test, with rusty metal slides, concrete under monkey bars, and swings designed to launch kids into orbit. Teachers often stood at a distance, assuming kids would just figure things out (or toughen up). Today, schools have strict safety rules, padded play areas, and teachers ready to intervene at the first sign of danger. Letting kids play without supervision now would be a lawsuit waiting to happen.

6. The “No Talking” Rule—Even at Lunch

Max Fischer on Pexels

Some schools had strict “silent lunch” policies, where kids weren’t allowed to talk, laugh, or even whisper while eating. Teachers would walk around monitoring noise levels and handing out punishments for even the smallest giggle. These days, socialization is seen as just as important as academics. Forcing kids to eat in silence would lead to complaints, protests, and probably a viral TikTok exposing the whole thing.

7. Making Kids Clean the Classroom as Punishment

Anna Shvets on Pexels

Schools used to treat students like unpaid janitors, assigning them to sweep floors, scrub desks, or clean bathrooms as punishment. Some even required kids to polish teachers’ shoes or wash chalkboards daily. If a teacher tried this today, parents would storm the principal’s office demanding an explanation. Now, schools hire actual janitors because kids aren’t there to be free labor.

8. Extreme Dress Codes (Especially for Girls)

Anastasia Shuraeva on Pexels

Girls were once sent home for showing their ankles, wearing pants, or having their skirts “too short” by an arbitrary measurement. Some schools required boys to wear ties every day, regardless of age or comfort. While dress codes still exist, today’s rules are more about fairness and safety rather than outdated ideas of “modesty.” A teacher enforcing those old-fashioned dress codes today would be in serious trouble.

9. Allowing Smoking on School Grounds

lil artsy on Pexels

Believe it or not, students and even teachers could smoke on campus in some schools well into the ’80s. Some schools had designated smoking areas for students, while teachers openly lit up in lounges. If a teacher smoked on school property today, they’d likely be fired before they finished their cigarette. Now, schools promote health, and smoking near kids is a huge no-no.

10. Failing or Holding Back Students for Petty Reasons

RDNE Stock project on Pexels

Teachers once had total control over whether a student passed or failed, sometimes based on personal grudges, handwriting neatness, or even classroom behavior. If a student angered the wrong teacher, they could be held back a grade—even if their academic work was fine. Today, grading is more standardized, and parents can challenge unfair academic decisions.