11 Forgotten Crimes That Shocked the Nation
This article discusses the 11 horrific crimes that captivated the country in the past but have received little attention. Mysteries, fears, and public outrage surrounded these long-forgotten cases when they were breaking news. The stories continue to evoke unease and haunting thoughts, even after all this time.
- Tricia Quitales
- 4 min read
While some atrocities remain etched in the annals of time, others go unremembered even though they shook the very foundations of our nation. These 11 terrifying crimes made headlines once but have since faded from public memory. These cases sparked curiosity, terror, and calls for justice, ranging from mysterious disappearances to daring heists. While they may not have the same level of fame as they once did, they all made an impression on American history.
1. The Disappearance of Paula Jean Welden (1946)
Quang Nguyen Vinh on Pexels
College student Paula Jean Welden vanished while hiking in Vermont and was never seen again. Her case sparked a massive manhunt and led to the creation of the Vermont State Police. Despite national attention, no clues were ever found.
2. The Wineville Chicken Coop Murders (1920s)
cottonbro studio on Pexels
This gruesome case involved a young boy’s disappearance and the discovery of multiple murdered children on a California farm. The crimes shocked the country and inspired the film Changeling. The case exposed serious flaws in police investigations at the time.
3. The Hall-Mills Murder Case (1922)
Sonny Sixteen on Pexels
A minister and a choir singer were found dead in a New Jersey field, and the case quickly became a national gossip. Their affair, the strange crime scene, and a suspicious cover-up captured headlines for weeks. To this day, no one has been convicted.
4. The Bath School Disaster (1927)
Strange Happenings on Pexels
This remains the deadliest school massacre in U.S. history, but few people remember it. A man bombed an elementary school in Michigan, killing 38 children and six adults. The scale of the tragedy left the nation horrified and confused.
5. The Boy in the Box (1957)
cottonbro studio on Pexels
A young boy’s body was found in a cardboard box in Philadelphia, and no one knew who he was. The mystery haunted police and the public for decades. Only recently have new leads emerged, but the case remains officially unsolved.
6. The Lindbergh Baby Trial’s Forgotten Details (1932)
Vlad Vasnetsov on Pexels
While everyone remembers the kidnapping of Charles Lindbergh’s son, many forget how strange and controversial the trial was. Questions about the evidence and whether the right man was convicted still linger. The case changed how America viewed child safety and law enforcement.
7. The Axeman of New Orleans (1918–1919)
Markus Spiske on Pexels
This serial killer broke into homes at night and attacked victims with an axe, creating a wave of panic in New Orleans. A chilling letter claimed he would spare anyone playing jazz, leading to a citywide musical frenzy. Despite the terror, the killer was never caught.
8. The Keddie Cabin Murders (1981)
Mateas Petru on Pexels
Four people were brutally murdered in a remote cabin in California, with little clear motive. Despite evidence and possible suspects, the case went cold for decades. New DNA testing is bringing it back into focus but still shocks those who hear about it.
9. The Cleveland Torso Murders (1930s)
Noé Villalta Photography on pexels
A serial killer left behind dismembered bodies around Cleveland, terrifying the city for years. Even legendary lawman Eliot Ness couldn’t solve the case. It remains one of the most disturbing and unsolved murder sprees in U.S. history.
10. The Murder of Helen Jewett (1836)
cottonbro studio on Pexels
A high-class New York City courtesan was found murdered in a scandalous case that involved sex, power, and the press. Her death divided public opinion and put journalism ethics on trial. It was one of the first American crimes to get nationwide media attention.
11. The Tylenol Murders (1982)
Alex Green on Pexels
Someone tampered with bottles of Tylenol, killing several people and causing panic across the country. The crime led to major changes in product safety and packaging. Despite an intense investigation, the killer was never found.