11 Holiday Traditions With Surprisingly Dark Origins
Here's a closer look at beloved holiday customs that actually began with unsettling or eerie beginnings.
- Daisy Montero
- 3 min read
Many holiday traditions we enjoy today actually come from much darker beginnings. Some started as rituals to scare away spirits, while others were tied to fear, sacrifice, or superstition. Over time, they were reshaped into the cheerful customs we know, but their history is far from light.
1. Christmas Carols and “Waits”
Halyna Kuchmanych on Wikimedia Commons
Before cheerful caroling, groups known as “waits” would sing at people’s doors — sometimes aggressively demanding food or drink in exchange. It was closer to rowdy extortion than holiday cheer. What we think of as sweet songs once carried a hint of menace.
2. Mistletoe and Human Sacrifice
Kaboompics.com on pexels
Today mistletoe means romance, but to ancient Druids it was a sacred plant tied to fertility rituals and sometimes sacrifice. It symbolized life and death, making its presence both mystical and unsettling. Your holiday kiss has roots far darker than you think.
3. Yule Logs and Pagan Fire Rituals
Lone Crow Photography on pexels
The cozy Yule log once came from Norse and Celtic rituals meant to ward off evil spirits during the darkest days of winter. Entire trees were burned slowly to symbolize survival. What feels like comfort today began as a defense against unseen forces.
4. Santa Claus and the Fearsome Krampus
Eddson Lens on pexels
Santa may be jolly now, but his European counterpart Krampus was a horned demon who punished bad children. Families told terrifying stories to keep kids obedient. The holiday season once blended warmth with outright fear.
5. New Year’s “First Footing” Superstition
Anna Shvets on pexels
In Scottish tradition, the first visitor through the door on New Year’s determined a household’s fortune. Dark-haired men were considered lucky, while blond or red-haired visitors were thought unlucky, recalling Viking raids. The custom blended hope with lingering fear of invasion.
6. Halloween and Samhain’s Spirits
Matheus Bertelli on pexels
Halloween traces back to Samhain, when Celts believed the dead roamed freely. People lit bonfires and wore disguises to confuse wandering spirits. The candy-filled fun of today hides centuries of fear and superstition.
7. Easter and Pagan Fertility Rituals
Jill Wellington on pexels
Easter’s eggs and bunnies are symbols of fertility from pagan spring celebrations. These rituals honored renewal and often included practices tied to sex and fertility. Over time, they were absorbed into Christian tradition with a softer meaning.
8. Trick-or-Treating as Soul Begging
Charles Parker on pexels
Long before costumes and candy, the poor went door-to-door on All Souls’ Day offering prayers for the dead in exchange for food. Known as “souling,” it had a solemn and sometimes desperate tone. Today’s candy hunt has roots in survival and mourning.
9. Fireworks on New Year’s Eve
rovenimages.com on pexels
Fireworks may look festive, but they were originally meant to scare away evil spirits. The loud explosions weren’t about celebration; they were a form of spiritual protection. Noise was literally used as a shield against darkness.
10. Carnival and Chaos Before Lent
Luis Fernandes on pexels
Carnival is colorful and joyous now, but it began as a time when people indulged in wild, chaotic behavior before the restrictions of Lent. It was often linked to drunkenness, sin, and mockery of authority. Underneath the masks was a darker spirit of rebellion.
11. Christmas Trees and Pagan Sun Worship
Dmitriy Steinke on pexels
Evergreen trees decorated for Christmas were originally symbols of life during the darkest winter months. Ancient cultures saw them as protection against spirits and as offerings to sun gods. What we see as festive décor began as a sacred ritual.