12 Candy Flavors That Disappeared Without Explanation
These discontinued candy flavors vanished from store shelves, leaving fans confused and craving more.
- Daisy Montero
- 3 min read
Some candy flavors just vanish overnight, leaving behind nothing but rumors and cravings. The flavors on this list once sparked sugar highs and childhood memories but are now just candy-coated mysteries. Get ready for a sugary walk down memory lane that ends in a whole lot of “wait, what happened to that?”
1. Mountain Dew’s Electric Apple Taffy
Steven Depolo from Grand Rapids, MI, USA on Wikimedia Commons
This sour green apple flavor had a bold citrus twist and came in taffy form for a brief time in the early 2000s. It never even made it past limited-release regions. People still swear it was the most unique green candy ever made.
2. Butterfinger BB’s Lime Blaster
Judgefloro on Wikimedia Commons
Nestlé once added a lime twist to the famous Butterfinger BBs, and it was as strange as it was short-lived. The lime flavor disappeared fast, almost as if it never happened. It left behind a trail of puzzled fans who just wanted one more bag.
3. Skittles Choco-Mint Fusion
TaurusEmerald on Wikimedia Commons
Skittles tried mixing dessert with freshness in this polarizing chocolate mint flavor. It quietly vanished after a short test run. People either loved it or never understood why mint was in a Skittle to begin with.
4. Pepsi Pop Rocks
Evan-Amos on Wikimedia Commons
Pop Rocks once had a Pepsi flavor that fizzed extra hard in your mouth. It mysteriously disappeared not long after its hype. It is now a candy legend, whispered about but rarely seen again.
5. Jelly Belly Draft Beer Beans
Brandon Dilbeck at English Wikipedia on Wikimedia Commons
Jelly Belly released a beer-flavored bean that was more foam than flavor. Some thought it was a joke, but it really existed. Then it quietly left shelves, as if the company wanted to forget it too.
6. Mars Bar Coconut Storm
User:Kirschblut on Wikimedia Commons
For a short while, Mars Bars came in a coconut version that gave Bounty a run for its money. It quietly vanished before many people even knew it existed. Those who tried it still talk about it like a ghost candy.
7. Reese’s Banana Cream Cups
The Hershey Company on Wikimedia Commons
Inspired by Elvis’s favorite flavor combo, this banana twist on a Reese’s Cup was released in select stores. It barely got attention before being pulled. Fans still beg for it to return every time Reese’s releases a new flavor.
8. Lifesavers Wint-O-Grape
Scott Ehardt on Wikimedia Commons
This grape-mint hybrid left more people confused than refreshed. It showed up in a seasonal pack and never came back. Even Lifesavers fan pages cannot explain what happened to it.
9. Hubba Bubba Root Beer Float
Unknown author on Wikimedia Commons
This gum flavor had the perfect mix of soda and vanilla, and it actually worked. However, it just vanished from shelves with no official word. Collectors sometimes trade sealed packs online for nostalgic gum fans.
10. Gobstopper Fruit Punch Frenzy
Eli the Bearded on Wikimedia Commons
Gobstopper once released a fruit punch version that changed colors and flavors as you ate. It had a short run and left just as quickly as it arrived. Many fans still think it was the best flavor they ever had.
11. Twizzlers Watermelon Lime
kennejima on Wikimedia Commons
Twizzlers took a risk with this combo, and surprisingly, it worked for a niche crowd. However, the bold flavor combo did not catch on with everyone. After a quiet run, it was gone and barely mentioned again.
12. Tootsie Roll Vanilla Berry Swirl
Evan-Amos on Wikimedia Commons
This rare edition tasted like candy cane and blueberry rolled into one chewy bite. It confused people during holiday seasons before being pulled off shelves. Today, it remains a curious blip in Tootsie’s long candy history.