12 Ice Cream Flavors Everyone Misses
Here's a nostalgic journey through 12 beloved ice cream flavors that disappeared from shelves but remain unforgettable to fans.
- Alyana Aguja
- 4 min read
Ice cream lovers often reminisce about discontinued flavors that brought unique textures and unforgettable tastes. From Ben & Jerry’s quirky creations like Wavy Gravy and Cool Britannia to Häagen-Dazs’ elegant Sticky Toffee Pudding and Banana Foster, each flavor had its own devoted following. Though gone, these lost favorites remain a sweet part of ice cream history, reminding us that the best flavors often vanish too soon.
1. Ben & Jerry’s Wavy Gravy
Image from Wikipedia
First introduced in the early 1990s, this funky flavor combined caramel and cashew Brazil nut ice cream with roasted almonds and chocolate hazelnut fudge swirls. Named after a famous counterculture figure, Wavy Gravy quickly built a cult following. Unfortunately, its complexity made it tough to maintain, leading to its retirement.
2. Baskin-Robbins’ French Cream Coffee
Image from Wikipedia
This elegant blend of rich coffee ice cream and smooth French cream was a favorite among coffee lovers. It had a velvety texture and a refined taste that stood out from sweeter dessert-like flavors. Many longtime Baskin-Robbins fans still talk about how much they miss this one-of-a-kind flavor.
3. Häagen-Dazs’ Banana Foster
Image from Wikipedia
Inspired by the classic New Orleans dessert, this limited-time flavor mixed caramelized banana ice cream with hints of brown sugar and rum. It was both decadent and comforting, bringing restaurant-level sophistication to the freezer aisle. Though short-lived, it left a lasting impression on dessert enthusiasts.
4. Ben & Jerry’s Rainforest Crunch
Image from Wikipedia
A true fan favorite, Rainforest Crunch blended vanilla ice cream with chocolate-covered cashew buttercrunch chunks. It was sweet, nutty, and crunchy, making it stand out among other textures. Sadly, sourcing rainforest-friendly nuts proved unsustainable, forcing Ben & Jerry’s to discontinue it.
5. Baskin-Robbins’ Apple Pie a La Mode
Image from Wikipedia
This seasonal flavor captured the taste of classic Americana with apple-flavored ice cream, real apple chunks, cinnamon, and pie crust pieces. It felt like eating a slice of warm apple pie straight out of the oven. Fans still beg for its return every fall.
6. Häagen-Dazs’ Vanilla Chocolate Chip
Image from Wikipedia
Though it sounds simple, this was one of Häagen-Dazs’ best-loved flavors. The creamy vanilla base paired perfectly with delicate chocolate chips, offering an elegant twist on a classic. Its sudden removal from shelves shocked many loyal fans.
7. Ben & Jerry’s Cool Britannia
Image from Wikipedia
Launched in the 1990s, this quirky flavor combined strawberry and vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered shortbread cookies. It was part of the brand’s playful British-themed lineup. Despite its popularity, it was eventually phased out to make room for newer experimental flavors.
8. Baskin-Robbins’ Lunar Cheesecake
Image from Wikipedia
Released during the excitement of moon exploration, this creative flavor blended cheesecake ice cream with graham cracker swirls and chunks of real cheesecake. It was indulgent and playful, capturing a sense of wonder. After its limited run, it became one of the most-requested discontinued flavors.
9. Häagen-Dazs’ Dulce de Leche Almond Bar Crunch
Image from Wikipedia
This indulgent treat mixed dulce de leche ice cream with caramel swirls and roasted almonds covered in chocolate. It was rich, nutty, and sweet, offering layers of texture in every spoonful. Fans still lament its disappearance from stores.
10. Ben & Jerry’s White Russian
Image from Wikipedia
Based on the classic cocktail, this flavor blended coffee ice cream with Kahlúa liqueur. It offered a sophisticated and boozy taste that adult fans adored. Unfortunately, changes in licensing and branding led to its early retirement.
11. Baskin-Robbins’ Black Walnut
Image from Wikipedia
This flavor highlighted the bold and earthy taste of black walnuts, a unique nut seldom used in mainstream ice cream. It was a more mature option compared to traditional sweet flavors. Once it disappeared, it left fans craving its distinct richness.
12. Häagen-Dazs’ Sticky Toffee Pudding
Image from Wikipedia
Inspired by the beloved British dessert, this flavor combined rich toffee ice cream with sponge cake pieces and a toffee swirl. It balanced sweetness with warmth, making it especially popular during the colder months. Sadly, it was only available for a short time before being discontinued.