12 School Fundraiser Items No One Wanted to Buy
Everyone remembers being handed a fundraiser packet and being told to sell as much as possible. The problem was that half the items were things no one actually wanted in the first place.
- Tricia Quitales
- 4 min read
School fundraisers were meant to help support field trips, sports teams, and classroom supplies, but not every item was a hit. Some products felt more like clutter than charitable purchases, leaving parents and neighbors politely declining. While the goal was noble, the items often missed the mark on practicality or appeal. These moments live on as reminders that good intentions do not always lead to great sales.
1. Overpriced Wrapping Paper
cottonbro studio on pexels
Glossy, colorful, and way too expensive, school fundraiser wrapping paper rarely found excited buyers. It was usually sold in small rolls that barely covered a single gift. Parents felt obligated to purchase, but the value just wasn’t there. Even around the holidays, cheaper and better options filled store shelves. Most of it ended up unused in a drawer.
2. Generic Scented Candles
KATRIN BOLOVTSOVA on pexels
The promise of a cozy-smelling home was often ruined by overly strong or artificial fragrances. The jars all looked the same, and the scents never quite matched their descriptions. Many people bought them out of pity and never actually lit them. Some just used them as emergency backup gifts. The quality rarely justified the price.
3. Plastic Keychains with School Logos
aboodi vesakaran on pexels
Intended to boost school spirit, these keychains felt more like filler than merchandise. The designs were usually outdated or too simple. Parents already had plenty of keychains, and students rarely used them. Most ended up at the bottom of backpacks or junk drawers. It was a hard sell every time.
4. Cookie Dough Tubs
Pavel Danilyuk on pexels
Though they sounded like a delicious idea, these massive tubs of frozen dough were more hassle than treat. They took up space in the freezer and never tasted quite right after baking. Some buyers forgot about them entirely, only to find them freezer-burned months later. The portion sizes were inconsistent, and the baking instructions were vague. Convenience stores had better, ready-to-bake options.
5. Magazine Subscriptions
Pixabay on pexels
Getting someone to commit to a year of reading a random magazine was never easy. Many options felt outdated or irrelevant, especially with the rise of digital content. People would subscribe out of guilt and never read a single issue. Some magazines arrived months late or not at all. It was more of a paperwork chore than a fundraiser.
6. Miniature Holiday Figurines
Tino Van Staeyen on pexels
These tiny ceramic or plastic figurines looked festive but lacked quality and charm. Most people didn’t know what to do with them after the holidays ended. They collected dust or were quietly donated to thrift shops. Students had trouble explaining why they cost so much. The seasonal appeal wore off fast.
7. Coupon Books for Local Businesses
RDNE Stock project on pexels
Packed with discounts that most people never used, these thick coupon books were difficult to justify. Many of the offers had short expiration dates or specific conditions. Buyers often flipped through them once and set them aside. The idea was great in theory, but the execution lacked usefulness. Some of the featured businesses even went out of business mid-year.
8. Reusable Shopping Bags with Corny Slogans
cottonbro studio on pexels
Eco-friendly in intention but tacky in design, these bags rarely made it into regular rotation. The fabric felt flimsy, and the slogans were awkward or unfunny. They were too small for actual grocery runs and too ugly for daily use. Buyers kept them out of guilt but rarely used them. It was one of the least practical fundraiser choices.
9. DIY Craft Kits
İlayda Akc on pexels
These kits promised hours of creative fun but often delivered frustration and mess. Instructions were unclear, and the materials felt cheap. Parents who bought them had to do most of the work themselves. Finished products never looked like the pictures. It was a guaranteed one-time purchase.
10. School-Themed Calendars
Jess Bailey Designs on Pexels
Featuring student art or photos from past events, these calendars felt more like souvenirs than useful tools. The designs were cluttered, and the paper quality was poor. By the time they arrived, the year was already a few months in. Most people already had digital calendars or better-designed alternatives. They ended up forgotten in kitchen drawers.
11. Inflated Balloons in Decorative Boxes
Polina Tankilevitch on pexels
Sold as gifts or room décor, these helium balloons arrived half-deflated or tangled. They were difficult to store and impossible to re-inflate once they lost air. The novelty wore off in hours, and the price was rarely worth it. Kids loved them briefly, but adults avoided them. They were more gimmick than fundraiser.
12. Gourmet Popcorn Tins
Pavel Danilyuk on pexels
These oversized tins came with three or four popcorn flavors, none of which were particularly great. The cheese and caramel varieties often tasted stale or too artificial. Once the popcorn was gone, people were left with a bulky metal tin they didn’t want. It became a storage problem more than a snack. Buyers often regretted it after the first handful.