12 School Punishments That Would Never Be Allowed Now

School was a much tougher place, not just because of homework. Decades ago, punishments were stricter, harsher, and often shocking by today’s standards. Here's a surprising look at old-school punishments that were once common—but would never fly in a modern classroom.

Tricia Quitales
April 21, 2025
3 min read

12 School Punishments That Would Never Be Allowed Now — Yan Krukau on Pexels

Discipline in schools has changed a lot over the years. What used to be considered a “normal” punishment is now seen as too extreme, outdated, or even abusive. Today, education leans more on understanding and positive reinforcement than fear. This article highlights 12 harsh school punishments from the past that have rightfully been left behind.

1. Corporal Punishment (Paddling)

Joel Bradshaw on Wikimedia

Getting spanked with a paddle by a teacher or principal was once a common way to deal with misbehavior. It was often done in front of classmates, adding embarrassment to the pain. Today, physical punishment is banned in most schools for obvious reasons.

2. Dunce Caps

cogdogblog on Wikimedia

Kids who didn’t understand a lesson fast enough were made to wear a pointed “dunce” cap and sit in the corner. It was meant to shame them into learning, but it often had the opposite effect. Now, we know that learning differences need support, not humiliation.

3. Writing Lines for Hours

Connor McManus on Pexels

“Write this sentence 500 times.” was a go-to punishment for talking back or forgetting homework. It caused sore hands and didn’t teach much beyond frustration. Modern schools focus more on reflection than repetition.

4. Standing in the Corner

Yan Krukau on pexels

Misbehaving students were told to stand facing the wall for long periods of time. This was isolating and boring and did little to solve the problem. Now, timeouts are shorter and designed to calm—not shame—the student.

5. Ruler Smacks on the Hand

Polina Zimmerman on pexels

Teachers would use wooden rulers to slap students’ hands for minor rule-breaking. The sound alone was enough to scare the whole class into silence. Today, this would be seen as abusive and completely unacceptable.

6. Staying After School Without Warning

Kaboompics.com on pexels

Students could be kept in detention without telling parents ahead of time. It was inconvenient, confusing, and sometimes scary for kids who relied on set routines. Now, parental communication is a key part of discipline.

7. Silent Lunches

Yan Krukau on pexels

Talking during lunch was banned as punishment, turning social time into a lonely experience. For some kids, it felt like more of a punishment than detention. Now, schools are more mindful of how isolation affects a child’s well-being.

8. Holding Heavy Books as Punishment

George Milton on pexels

Students were made to stand with arms stretched out, holding books for long stretches. This punishment was exhausting and could cause physical pain. Today, punishments involving physical discomfort are no longer allowed.

9. Public Shaming in Front of Class

Tima Miroshnichenko on Pexels

Calling out students by name for bad grades or poor behavior was once a routine. It embarrassed the child and hurt their confidence. Now, teachers are trained to handle issues privately and respectfully.

10. Cleaning the Classroom as Discipline

Pixabay on pexels

Messy classroom? Make the troublemaker clean it up. While it taught responsibility, it was often used in a way that felt like punishment instead of learning.

11. Sending Kids Outside the Classroom Alone

cottonbro studio on pexels

Being kicked out of class meant standing in the hallway unsupervised, sometimes for an entire lesson. It removed the child from learning rather than helping them re-engage. Today’s strategies aim to bring students back into focus, not out the door.

12. Name and Shame on the Chalkboard

Heiner on pexels

Some teachers wrote students’ names under a “bad behavior” list on the board. This was meant to embarrass them into acting better. Now, we know that shaming doesn’t change behavior—it just damages self-esteem.