12 Toys From the 1990s That Are Collector’s Gold Now

These '90s toys once filled toy chests across the world, but today, they’re prized collector’s items worth a surprising amount.

Daisy Montero
November 13, 2025
4 min read

12 Toys From the 1990s That Are Collector’s Gold Now — Dimitrije Djekanovic on Pexels

The 1990s brought out some of the most memorable toys ever made, and many of them are now worth a lot to collectors. What used to be everyday playthings have turned into valuable treasures. Here are some of the most popular toys from the ’90s that people still look for today.

1. 1. Pokémon Cards

Pokémon cards were a playground currency in the late ’90s, traded and battled among friends. Rare holographic cards like Charizard have become prized possessions among collectors today. Their nostalgic pull and limited releases make them highly valuable. Many enthusiasts now see them as both memories and investments.

2. 2. Nintendo Game Boy

The Game Boy defined portable gaming for an entire generation. Its chunky design and pixelated screen captured countless hours of playtime. Original models and limited-edition versions are now collectors’ favorites. Having one in mint condition can easily raise its value among vintage tech fans.

3. 3. Tamagotchi

Nori Norisa from 熊谷市, Japan on Wikimedia Commons

These digital pets demanded constant care and attention from kids everywhere. The tiny egg-shaped gadget became a must-have accessory. Today, early Tamagotchi models are being sold to collectors who crave a bit of ’90s virtual pet chaos. Their charm lies in their simplicity and the memories they bring back.

4. 4. Beanie Babies

daryl_mitchell from Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada on Wikimedia Commons

Beanie Babies sparked a craze that took the ’90s by storm. Collectors believed they would skyrocket in value, and for some rare ones, they actually did. Certain limited-edition releases are now worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. They remain a soft reminder of ’90s childhood dreams and collector hopes.

5. 5. Polly Pocket

Tiny worlds in colorful compacts made Polly Pocket irresistible to ’90s kids. Each miniature set opened to reveal detailed little scenes and characters. Original versions are now collector treasures due to their craftsmanship and nostalgic charm. The newer versions may sparkle more, but the originals hold true vintage magic.

6. 6. Furby

Furbies were both adorable and slightly creepy, and kids could not get enough of them. These talking, blinking creatures were a holiday must-have. Original Furbies, still in their boxes, now fetch high prices online. Collectors love their quirky appeal and the way they capture late ’90s toy culture.

7. 7. LEGO Sets

InSapphoWeTrust from Los Angeles, California, USA on Wikimedia Commons

LEGO was already popular long before the ’90s, but sets from that decade now hold serious collector value. Themes like Space Police and Pirates are especially sought after. Sealed boxes can command impressive prices today. Each set tells a story of creative play and early imagination.

8. 8. Power Rangers Action Figures

The Mighty Morphin Power Rangers were heroes of every ’90s kid’s imagination. Their action figures brought the show’s battles to life in bedrooms everywhere. Collectors now chase rare editions and complete sets. The bright costumes and nostalgia factor make them timeless collectibles.

9. 9. Hot Wheels Cars

Hot Wheels have been around since the ’60s, but the ’90s brought some standout models. Special editions and themed sets have become collector favorites. Mint condition cars in original packaging are worth far more than their retail price. Each one is a small piece of automotive art.

10. 10. Sega Genesis

The Sega Genesis was a staple in many ’90s living rooms. Its library of games and distinctive controller design made it a favorite for gamers. Original consoles and cartridges now hold collector value, especially in working condition. The system still represents an exciting era of home gaming.

11. 11. My Little Pony Figures

My Little Pony had a devoted fanbase throughout the ’90s. The figures were bright, detailed, and endlessly collectible. First-edition ponies in good condition are now valuable to collectors. Their colorful manes and friendly faces make them timeless symbols of ’90s playtime.

12. 12. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Action Figures

Agencia de Noticias ANDES on Wikimedia Commons

These heroes in a half-shell ruled the ’90s toy scene. Kids collected figures of Leonardo, Michelangelo, Donatello, and Raphael to re-create epic battles. Today, complete sets and rare editions fetch impressive prices. They remain among the most beloved toy lines of the decade.