14 VHS Rental Rules We All Knew by Heart
Back when renting movies was a weekend ritual, there were unspoken VHS rules that everyone followed.
- Sophia Zapanta
- 6 min read
Before streaming took over, renting a VHS was an event that came with its own set of rules. Everyone knew them, whether it was about rewinding tapes or avoiding late fees. Let’s rewind and revisit the 14 VHS rental rules we all lived by.
1. Always Rewind the Tape Before Returning It
Ron Lach on Pexels
Nothing was worse than popping in a VHS only to find it at the credits. If you didn’t rewind, you were officially a terrible person, and the next renter cursed your name. Some video stores even charged a rewind fee just to make sure people behaved. The best ones had those high-speed rewinders that made a satisfying whirring sound.
2. Return Your Rentals on Time or Face the Consequences
Anthony on Wikimedia Commons
Late fees weren’t just a couple of cents—they could turn your $3 rental into a financial crisis. If you kept a tape too long, the store basically charged you enough to buy it outright. Returning a movie late meant walking in with guilt, avoiding eye contact, and hoping no one noticed. The real pros set alarms to avoid the disaster of forgetting.
3. Never Hog the New Releases
Lucas Pezeta on Pexels
Everybody wanted the hottest new movie, so it was bad form to keep it for more than a night or two. If you were lucky enough to snag a copy, you watched it ASAP and brought it back so someone else could enjoy it. Holding onto it too long was basically community service abuse. You were officially selfish if you tried to rent it again right after returning it.
4. Respect the First-Come, First-Served System
Ron Lach on Pexels
There were no reservations or online holds—if you didn’t get there early, too bad. Hovering near the return bin hoping to snatch a fresh drop-off was fair game, but cutting in line was a crime. Asking employees to “check the back” was a desperate move, and the answer was always no. If someone else grabbed the last copy, you had to accept defeat.
5. Pick a Movie Quickly—No Endless Browsing
Ron Lach on Pexels
Standing in the aisles for an hour, indecisively picking up and putting down the same movies, was unacceptable. If you came with friends or family, you had about 10 minutes before they lost patience. Grabbing three movies, debating them, and then putting two back at the last second was classic behavior. The worst offenders were the ones who waited until checkout to start second-guessing.
6. Don’t Complain About Scratched or Messed-Up Tapes
Corentin HENRY on Pexels
Everyone knew rental tapes weren’t in perfect condition. If you got one with a weird tracking issue or a section that glitched, you just dealt with it. Returning it and whining to the employees changed nothing—they’d just put it back on the shelf for the next sucker. If you were smart, you had a VCR with manual tracking controls to fix the problem yourself.
7. Horror Section Browsing Was a Rite of Passage
Kutay Ertürk on Pexels
Even if you weren’t renting one, you had to wander into the horror section just to test your courage. The VHS covers were so terrifying they sometimes scared you more than the actual movies. Some stores had a tiny back room for extra scary stuff, and you peeked in just to feel dangerous. The bravest rented a horror movie just to prove they could handle it—then slept with the lights on.
8. Don’t Hoard the Store’s Rental Card
cottonbro studio on Pexels
If your family shared one membership, you had to return the card when you got home. Losing it was like losing the remote—suddenly, no one could rent anything until it was found. If you took the card without permission, you’d better not rack up late fees or rent something embarrassing. Forgetting the card at the store meant a lecture from your parents.
9. The Return Drop Slot Was for Speedy Exits Only
Anthony on Wikimedia Commons
Returning a movie through the drop slot was the move when you were running late—or avoiding confrontation. If you knew your tape was overdue, you tossed it in and walked away like nothing happened. If you thought you were on time but weren’t, you’d check your account nervously on your next visit. Dropping off a tape and immediately going inside to rent it again was sneaky but effective.
10. Don’t Take Forever at the Counter
Kampus Production on Pexels
If there was a line, you had to be fast—this wasn’t a time for chit-chat or indecisiveness. Forgetting your membership card, questioning late fees, or trying to argue about pricing was not acceptable. The people behind you were mad that you got the last copy of the best movie. If you needed movie recommendations, that was an off-peak-hours conversation.
11. If You Damaged a Tape, You Were Paying for It
Swapnil Sharma on Wikimedia Commons
Tapes weren’t invincible, and if yours got eaten by the VCR, it was your fault. Snapping the film, spilling soda on it, or losing the case meant an awkward conversation at the register. Some people tried to tape them back together, hoping no one would notice. However, the moment the next renter complained, the store knew exactly who to blame.
12. You Weren’t Allowed to Rent the Same Movie a Million Times
Катерина Санна on Pexels
Everybody had that one movie they rented constantly, but after a while, employees started noticing. If they gave you a weird look, it was time to just buy the movie already. Some stores even had a limit on how many times you could rent the same title. If you knew you’d rent it more than three times, it was a bad financial decision not to own it.
13. No Fast-Forwarding Through the FBI Warning
Ron Lach on Pexels
That big blue FBI warning screen was like a pre-movie ritual. It was too long, unnecessarily aggressive, and made you feel guilty for no reason. Even if you tried, most rental tapes wouldn’t let you skip it, so you just suffered in silence. The real rebels fast-forwarded anyway, pretending they weren’t scared of government surveillance.
14. Finding a Movie You Wanted Was Like Winning the Lottery
cottonbro studio on Pexels
If a movie you’d been searching for was actually on the shelf, it felt like fate. You grabbed it as fast as possible, just in case someone else was eyeing it. The whole way to the counter, you guarded it like treasure. That moment alone made the entire trip worth it.