15 Board Games from the Past That Were Strangely Dark
Board games have long been a staple of family entertainment, bringing people together through strategy, luck, and playful competition. While many games are designed to be fun and lighthearted, some older titles ventured into surprisingly grim or unsettling territory.
- Tricia Quitales
- 5 min read
What may seem inappropriate or uncomfortable by today’s standards was once marketed as wholesome fun. These vintage games often carried eerie themes, questionable messages, or downright morbid objectives. They serve as cultural time capsules, highlighting past societal norms, fears, and curiosities. Looking back at these strange board games offers a fascinating perspective on the evolution of play and morality.
1. Public Assistance: Why Bother Working?
cottonbro studio on Pexels
This controversial 1980s game mocked welfare recipients and promoted harsh stereotypes. Players earned more money through scams than through honest work. It faced immediate backlash for being offensive and insensitive. The game was eventually pulled but remains a disturbing example of political commentary in gaming.
2. The Game of Life (Original 1860 Version)
Margarita Kainova on Pexels
Milton Bradley’s original version was far darker than today’s version. It ended with players reaching either “Happy Old Age” or “Ruin,” with consequences like crime and poverty. The board included grim fates such as “Disgrace” and “Idleness.” Its morality-heavy message reflected strict Victorian values.
3. Ghettopoly
Kaboompics.com on Pexels
A blatant parody of Monopoly, Ghettopoly was filled with racist stereotypes and offensive depictions of urban life. It featured drug dealing, prostitution, and police brutality as gameplay elements. Public outrage led to lawsuits and its removal from stores. The game is now widely condemned as deeply inappropriate.
4. Milton Bradley’s Concentration Camp Game
Rayhan Patuary on Pexels
Though rarely seen today, early 20th-century Europe saw games themed around concentration camps during wartime propaganda. Some editions gamified the process of arresting and transporting people. These titles were later banned or erased from catalogs. They remain a disturbing footnote in both gaming and political history.
5. Life as a Blackman
Victor Ebeku on Pexels
Marketed in the 1990s, this game attempted to simulate the challenges of growing up as a Black man in America. While it aimed to educate, critics argued it leaned into stereotypes and offered a bleak worldview. Players navigated discrimination, violence, and systemic inequality. Its tone sparked debate over intent versus impact.
6. Dirty Minds
Катерина Жосул on Pexels
Marketed as an adult wordplay game, Dirty Minds walked the line between humor and suggestiveness. Clues seemed filthy but had innocent answers, creating awkward conversations in mixed groups. While not gruesome, its innuendo-heavy format made it controversial in some households. The game still exists but is often met with caution.
7. Serial Killer Trivia Game
Nika Benedictova on Pexels
This indie trivia game focused entirely on facts about real-life serial killers. Critics called it tasteless and exploitative, especially due to its glamorization of violent criminals. Despite its niche popularity, many stores refused to carry it. It remains an unsettling curiosity among true crime fans.
8. Mystery Date: Catfishing Edition
Ricardo Utsumi on Pexels
This was a modern spinoff that added a dark twist to a once-innocent dating game. Players risked landing a date with a deceiver rather than a dream guy. While intended to reflect online dating risks, many found it disturbing and predatory. The game’s reception was mixed, leading to a limited release.
9. War on Terror: The Boardgame
Karyme França on Pexels
Launched in the early 2000s, this satirical game mocked global politics and post-9/11 conflicts. Players could fund terrorist actions and wear an “Evil” balaclava during play. Governments and retailers criticized it for poor taste. Despite the outrage, it developed a cult following for its dark humor.
10. Don’t Wake Daddy (Original Concept)
Beatriz Braga on Pexels
Before it became a kids’ game about sneaking to the fridge, the original concept had darker undertones. Some early versions depicted punishment for disturbing a resting father, with surprisingly harsh consequences. Later versions were toned down significantly. It’s a subtle example of how themes were sanitized over time.
11. Capital Punishment Board Game
Vincent M.A. Janssen on Pexels
A niche title from the 1980s, this game asked players to choose whether criminals deserved execution. It combined court trials with grim moral decisions. Critics slammed it for trivializing the death penalty. It vanished quickly but left a strong impression on those who encountered it.
12. Medical Monopoly
cottonbro studio on Pexels
A darker take on hospital management, this game involved bankrupting patients and profiting from illness. Players earned money from extended stays and unnecessary treatments. Its satirical lens on healthcare struck a nerve. Though meant as a critique, it was too morbid for mainstream success.
13. Journey Through Europe (Nazi Propaganda Version)
Suzy Hazelwood on Pexels
Nazi Germany produced altered versions of children’s games with propaganda messaging. One such game had players travel through occupied Europe while promoting the Nazi worldview. These games were tools of indoctrination under the guise of fun. Few remain today due to their deeply disturbing origins.
14. Hit the Hippo!
cottonbro studio on Pexels
This was a 1970s children’s game that encouraged smacking a hippo figure with a mallet. While playful on the surface, it drew criticism for promoting themes of animal cruelty. Some versions were recalled after parent complaints. It’s now remembered as an example of poorly thought-out mechanics.
15. Booby-Trap (Original Version)
cottonbro studio on Pexels
This tension-based game had players pulling pieces from a spring-loaded trap, but the marketing leaned heavily on the term “booby” in a juvenile way. The suggestive advertising made the game controversial, despite its relatively tame design. Over time, the branding was refined for a broader audience. It remains in circulation but with more family-friendly packaging.