15 Discontinued ’90s Cookie Brands That We Still Crave
The 1990s were packed with unforgettable snacks, and cookies were at the center of the fun. Some brands made such an impact that their disappearance still stings for nostalgic snack lovers.
- Tricia Quitales
- 5 min read
Many ’90s cookie brands that once filled lunchboxes and kitchen shelves have vanished from stores, yet they remain etched in our memories. Changing trends, shifting consumer preferences, and company consolidations led to the disappearance of some truly beloved treats. These discontinued cookies brought unique flavors, textures, and branding that defined a generation.
1. Keebler Magic Middles
Evan-Amos on Wikimedia
These cookies featured a crumbly shortbread exterior with a soft chocolate or peanut butter center. They were a lunchbox favorite and loved for their surprise filling. Magic Middles had a unique texture combination that was hard to beat. Despite their popularity, they were discontinued without much explanation. Fans still beg for their return in snack forums and online petitions.
2. Giggles Cookies
Brigitte Tohm on Pexels
Giggles were sandwich cookies with smiling faces stamped into the top layer. Each cookie had a sweet cream filling in vanilla and chocolate varieties. Their playful design made them especially appealing to kids. They vanished from shelves as the cookie market grew more competitive. Many still remember the cheerful faces as a comforting part of their childhood.
3. Nabisco Swiss Cheese Cookies
Nati on Pexels
This lesser-known treat wasn’t sweet but was technically a cookie. These savory cheese-flavored crackers were shaped like Swiss cheese with holes. Though odd by today’s standards, they were a hit for snackers who wanted something different. They disappeared quietly in the mid-’90s. Only the most dedicated snack fans remember them now.
4. Melody Cookies
Beyzaa Yurtkuran on Pexels
Produced by Nabisco, Melody cookies were crisp, chocolate wafers without the cream. They were used in baking or eaten plain by dark chocolate lovers. Oreo fans often stumbled upon these and enjoyed the pure cocoa flavor. Nabisco quietly discontinued them without explanation. They remain a top-requested return on vintage snack lists.
5. PB Max
Marta Dzedyshko on Pexels
While technically a candy-bar-cookie hybrid, PB Max deserves a mention. It featured peanut butter, oats, and a cookie base covered in milk chocolate. It was rich, indulgent, and had a huge fan base. Mars Inc. discontinued it despite strong sales, reportedly because the company leadership disliked peanut butter. It remains one of the most missed cookie-based snacks.
6. Dunkaroos (Original 1990s Version)
ROMAN ODINTSOV on Pexels
Dunkaroos technically came back, but the original version was very different. The ’90s packs had cookies in unique shapes and thick, funfetti-style icing. They were a favorite in lunchboxes across the country. When they returned in the 2020s, the texture and flavor had changed slightly. Many still crave the exact original formula from the ’90s.
7. Oatmeal Swirlers
Madison Inouye on Pexels
These were packets of oatmeal with flavored cookie-like jelly you could swirl in yourself. Kids loved playing with their food while eating a semi-sweet breakfast. While not technically a dessert cookie, they satisfied that craving. Oatmeal Swirlers were discontinued after only a few years. People still bring them up in nostalgic breakfast threads.
8. Bug Bites by Nabisco
Vidal Balielo Jr. on Pexels
Bug Bites were small graham cookies shaped like insects. They came in individual snack packs, ideal for kids’ lunches. Sweet and simple, they were marketed toward younger children. As new snack trends emerged, these cheerful treats faded away. Many now recall them as a quirky part of their childhood snack routine.
9. Kudos Cookies & Cream Bars
solod_sha on Pexels
While primarily a granola bar, the cookies and cream version of Kudos had the soul of a dessert cookie. It included cookie bits, icing, and chocolate coating. Kids loved them as a sweeter alternative to traditional bars. Eventually, they were phased out as healthier snack options became more popular. People still long for their return, especially the cookies and cream flavor.
10. P.B. Crisps
cottonbro studio on Pexels
These crisp, peanut butter-filled snacks had a crunchy cookie-like shell. They were part of Planters’ foray into the cookie snack world. The combination of salty and sweet made them wildly addictive. Discontinued in the late ’90s, they still have a loyal fan base. Many petitions have called for their revival.
11. Oreo Big Stuf
RDNE Stock project on Pexels
Oreo Big Stuf cookies were massive versions of the original, packed individually. Each cookie was about ten times the size of a regular Oreo. Marketed toward teens, they offered an over-the-top snack experience. Production ended in the early 1990s due to changing portion size trends. Despite this, they are still talked about as a beloved novelty.
12. Teddy Grahams Dippers
Tim Douglas on pexels
These snacks combined the charm of Teddy Grahams with a small cup of frosting or chocolate for dipping. The experience was interactive and extra sweet. They disappeared as more grab-and-go healthy snacks came to market. While Teddy Grahams still exist, the dipper version is sorely missed. Fans remember them for their fun and indulgence.
13. Sprinkle Spangles
Agustina R Street on Pexels
Although a cereal, it often doubled as a cookie-like treat due to its sugary taste and cookie-like pieces. The star-shaped cereal was loaded with sprinkles and fun branding. Kids treated it more like dessert than breakfast. It didn’t last long before being discontinued in the mid-90s. Still, it holds a place in many nostalgic snack memories.
14. Chips Ahoy! Creamwiches
Polina Tankilevitch on Pexels
These sandwich-style cookies featured a layer of frosting between two chewy Chips Ahoy! cookies. They were rich, sweet, and indulgent. Marketed toward kids and teens, they offered a cookie twist on the ice cream sandwich. Creamwiches were pulled from shelves quietly, likely due to changing health trends. People still search for them in discontinued snack archives.
15. Crème Savers Cookies
Gaspar Zaldo on Pexels
Based on the popular hard candy, these cookies tried to capture the same fruity cream flavor. They had a smooth, soft texture and a fruity filling. While their uniqueness intrigued some, they didn’t gain lasting traction. Still, many remember them for their unusual blend of fruit and cookie. They disappeared quickly but remain a fun ’90s curiosity.