15 Things Most People Get Wrong About Cinco de Mayo—and What It’s Really About
Cinco de Mayo is widely misunderstood and often misrepresented, especially in the United States, where its historical significance is often overlooked.
- Sophia Zapanta
- 5 min read
Cinco de Mayo marks Mexico’s victory over French forces at the Battle of Puebla in 1862, not its independence. The day is largely celebrated in the United States, often disconnected from its historical meaning. In Mexico, it is a regional event with limited national recognition.
1. It is not Mexico’s Independence Day
Myotus on Wikimedia Commons
Mexico’s actual Independence Day is September 16, not May 5. Cinco de Mayo marks a specific military victory during a different conflict. The day commemorates the Battle of Puebla, where Mexican forces defeated the French army. This confusion is one of the most common misconceptions.
2. It is celebrated more in the United States than in Mexico
Penny Richards on Wikimedia Commons
In the United States, Cinco de Mayo is often seen as a major celebration, particularly among Mexican American communities. In Mexico, the day is mainly observed in the state of Puebla, with official events such as parades and educational activities. It is not a nationwide public holiday. Many Mexicans treat it like any other day.
3. The holiday honors one battle, not the end of a war
Missvain on Wikimedia Commons
Cinco de Mayo commemorates the Mexican army’s victory in a single battle in 1862. The French later regrouped and occupied Mexico City in 1863. The broader conflict continued for several years before Mexico fully expelled the French in 1867. The Battle of Puebla was important but not the final outcome.
4. France invaded Mexico over unpaid debts
SounderBruce on Wikimedia Commons
France, along with Britain and Spain, sent forces to Mexico to demand debt repayment. Britain and Spain later withdrew, but France stayed and pursued deeper involvement. Napoleon III wanted to establish influence in the Americas through a French-backed monarchy, which led to the military conflict.
5. Cinco de Mayo is not a federal holiday in Mexico
AthenaGabo on Wikimedia Commons
The date is recognized but is not a national public holiday. Only some schools and government offices close in certain regions. Most businesses remain open across the country. The day is mostly marked in the state of Puebla.
6. The holiday has political roots in the United States
Missvain on Wikimedia Commons
Mexican Americans began celebrating Cinco de Mayo during the 1960s as a way to promote cultural pride and civil rights. The battle served as a symbol of resistance and strength. These celebrations were tied to identity and community. The original meaning was not about leisure or partying.
7. The battle had indirect effects on the U.S. Civil War
Myotus on Wikimedia Commons
Some historians believe that if France had taken control of Mexico sooner, it might have supported the Confederacy. The Battle of Puebla delayed French progress and reduced their influence during a critical time. This helped limit European interference in the U.S. Civil War. The event had consequences beyond Mexico.
8. Alcohol is not traditionally part of the celebration in Mexico
Myotus on Wikimedia Commons
In Mexico, especially in Puebla, the day is marked with official ceremonies, parades, and school activities. It is not centered around parties or drinking. The association with alcohol is a later development in the United States. It does not reflect traditional observance.
9. Commercial marketing shaped modern U.S. celebrations
Missvain on Wikimedia Commons
Large alcohol companies in the United States began promoting Cinco de Mayo in the 1980s. They used it as a campaign to sell beer and spirits, especially to young adults. Over time, this turned a cultural event into a marketing opportunity, changing public understanding of the holiday.
10. U.S. schools often teach the holiday incorrectly
Warren K. Leffler on Wikimedia Commons
Many American students grew up thinking Cinco de Mayo is Mexico’s Independence Day. This is sometimes due to a lack of proper history education. Classroom lessons may simplify the story or skip over important context. As a result, the confusion continues for many adults.
11. Celebrations in Mexico are limited to certain areas
Myotus on Wikimedia Commons
Most of the formal events take place in Puebla, where the original battle occurred. Other cities may acknowledge the date, but usually in a smaller way. There are a few national celebrations. It is not considered a major day across the entire country.
12. Mexico lost later battles in the same war
Homan05 on Wikimedia Commons
Although Mexican forces won at Puebla in 1862, the French returned with more troops and captured Mexico City. They installed Maximilian I as emperor in 1864. Mexican resistance continued, and the French were eventually forced out. The war lasted five years beyond the initial victory.
13. Traditional foods are specific to the region
Missvain on Wikimedia Commons
In Puebla, foods like mole poblano are often prepared on Cinco de Mayo. These dishes are complex and rooted in local culture. Common American foods like nachos or burritos are not part of traditional observances. The U.S. version of the holiday includes many items that are not historically accurate.
14. Many Mexicans do not relate to the American version of the holiday
Missvain on Wikiemedia Commons
Mexicans outside Puebla often do not recognize May 5 as a significant date. The party-oriented style of U.S. celebrations can feel disconnected or inappropriate. There is a cultural gap between the historical meaning and the current image abroad. This can lead to misunderstandings on both sides.
15. The meaning of the day is tied to national resistance
Constantino Escalante on Wikimedia Commons
The Battle of Puebla became a symbol of standing up to stronger forces. It represents resilience and national pride. These values are central to the observance in Puebla. The holiday is about remembering courage, not recreation.