15 Times Jimmy Butler Took Over a Game

Jimmy Butler has a habit of showing up when the lights shine brightest, taking control of games in a way only true stars can. Whether it’s clutch shots, key steals, or putting the team on his back, he knows how to shift the momentum. Throughout his career, Butler has created highlight moments that have left fans and opponents alike in awe.

Tricia Quitales
June 8, 2025
4 min read

15 Times Jimmy Butler Took Over a Game — © Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

Jimmy Butler has delivered some of the most electric and gritty performances in modern basketball. Known for his toughness and leadership, he often steps up when the stakes are high and the game is on the line. These 15 moments showcase how Butler took full control, changing the course of matchups with his willpower and skill. From playoffs to regular season surprises, he’s proved he can dominate on both ends of the floor.

1. 2020 NBA Finals Game 3 vs. Lakers

With his team down 2–0 in the Finals and missing key players, Butler delivered a 40-point triple-double. He attacked the paint relentlessly and played 45 minutes without slowing down. It was a masterclass in leadership and effort.

2. Game 6 vs. Celtics, 2023 Eastern Conference Finals

Facing elimination, Butler calmly scored 28 points and hit big shots in the fourth quarter. He didn’t force anything but took over when it mattered most. His poise pushed the Heat to the NBA Finals once again.

3. 56-Point Explosion vs. Bucks, 2023 Playoffs

In one of the best playoff performances ever, Butler scored 56 points to take a 3–1 series lead. He hit everything, from deep threes to contested drives. That night, he looked completely unstoppable.

4. Game 1 vs. Bucks, 2023 First Round

Butler opened the playoffs with 35 points and 11 assists, setting the tone for the series. He tore through Milwaukee’s defense with surgical precision. It was clear the Heat were not there to be an easy out.

5. 2022 Game 6 vs. Celtics, Eastern Conference Finals

Butler scored 47 points with his season on the line. Every shot felt like it came from pure willpower. He carried the Heat single-handedly to a Game 7.

6. 2018 Regular Season vs. Hornets (with 76ers)

Playing for Philadelphia, Butler nailed a game-winning three in overtime. It was a quiet game until the end when he flipped a switch. That single shot made a loud statement about who he was in crunch time.

7. 2020 Bubble Game vs. Bucks

In Game 1 of the second round, Butler scored 40 points against the top-seeded Bucks. He took over the fourth quarter completely, scoring 15 straight points. The Heat rode that wave through the whole series.

8. 2021 vs. Rockets Triple-Double Run

Butler recorded his third triple-double in four games during a regular-season win against Houston. He wasn’t flashy but controlled every aspect of the game. His leadership pushed Miami back into playoff contention.

9. 2022 vs. Hawks, First Round Game 2

With 45 points, Butler dominated both ends of the floor. He played aggressive defense and hit timely threes. Atlanta had no answers for his energy and versatility.

10. 2015 vs. Pacers (with Bulls)

Butler scored 28 of his 35 points in the second half to erase a double-digit lead. He outworked everyone and inspired a comeback win. It was one of his early signs of future greatness.

11. 2021 vs. Suns, Regular Season Win

Against a strong Phoenix squad, Butler scored 29 and grabbed eight rebounds in a Miami win. He dictated the tempo and never allowed the Suns to find their rhythm. His mix of physical play and patience paid off big.

12. 2019 vs. Raptors, Regular Season Overtime Thriller

In a dramatic finish, Butler sank back-to-back jumpers in overtime to seal the victory. He played both ends with fire, diving for loose balls and contesting every shot. It was vintage Butler grit.

13. 2014 Playoffs vs. Wizards (with Bulls)

Butler showed flashes of dominance with lockdown defense and crucial buckets. Although the Bulls didn’t win the series, he left a lasting impression. His intensity was already at a playoff level.

14. 2023 Game 5 vs. Bucks, Series Clincher

He scored 42 points, including the game-tying bucket to force overtime. The Heat completed the upset, thanks largely to Butler’s focus and fire. It was a closing act worthy of a legend.

15. 2020 Finals Game 5 vs. Lakers

Down 3–1, Butler gave everything he had with 35 points, 12 rebounds, and 11 assists. He barely rested and hit clutch shots down the stretch. Though Miami lost the series, that performance kept their hopes alive and showed Butler’s true heart.