15 Toys That Were Pulled After Mysterious Incidents

Not every toy on store shelves is safe; some had to vanish after strange and unsettling events. From creepy sounds to unexpected injuries, these toys sparked fear, confusion, and even rumors before being recalled. Parents were left with more questions than answers; in some cases, so were the manufacturers.

Tricia Quitales
May 5, 2025
4 min read

15 Toys That Were Pulled After Mysterious Incidents — Suzy Hazelwood on Pexels

Toys are meant to bring joy, but sometimes they carry secrets that lead to frightening consequences. Over the years, a number of popular toys were pulled from shelves after mysterious and disturbing incidents. Whether it was unexplained behavior, hidden dangers, or eerie side effects, each toy on this list had something more than just a broken part. Let’s explore 15 toys that disappeared after raising eyebrows — and in some cases, real concern.

1. Cabbage Patch Snacktime Kids (1996)

Appalachian Artworks, Inc on Wikimedia

These dolls had motorized mouths to “eat” plastic snacks but didn’t know when to stop. Several children reported fingers and hair getting caught and pulled into the doll’s mouth. Mattel quickly pulled the product after parents raised serious safety concerns.

2. Aqua Dots (2007)

Tirachard Kumtanom on Pexels

A popular craft toy that used colorful beads turned dangerous when ingested. The beads were coated in a chemical that metabolized into a drug similar to GHB, causing seizures and blackouts in children. After multiple hospitalizations, the product was pulled worldwide.

3. Furby (1998)

furbymama on Pixabay

While never officially recalled, many households reported Furbies “waking up” at night or repeating words they were never taught. Rumors spread that they were recording conversations, causing fear and bans in some workplaces. The toy’s unpredictable behavior sparked enough panic that some stores temporarily pulled it.

4. Sky Dancers (1994)

Wolf Art on pexels

These flying fairy toys looked magical but came with sharp spinning wings. Numerous children suffered eye injuries, cuts, and even broken teeth after being hit. After over 100 reported injuries, the toy was taken off the market.

5. Magnetix Building Sets (2006)

Mizuno K on Pexels

Tiny, powerful magnets inside these toys could come loose and be swallowed. If more than one was ingested, they could attract inside the body, causing serious internal damage. A tragic death and several surgeries led to a massive recall.

6. CSI: Fingerprint Examination Kit (2007)

Arina Krasnikova on Pexels

A toy based on the hit TV show let kids dust for prints, but the powder contained asbestos. A consumer safety group discovered the dangerous substance, sparking immediate outrage. The toy was quickly pulled from shelves due to potential cancer risks.

7. Harry Potter Broomstick (2001)

Daisy Anderson on pexels

Meant to simulate flying fun, this toy broomstick vibrated during play. However, reports emerged of injuries in private areas, especially among younger children. Embarrassing complaints and safety concerns led to its quiet removal.

8. Snacktime Cabbage Patch Kids (Revisited)

Appalachian Artworks, Inc on Wikimedia

The doll’s mouth used rollers that didn’t stop once it started. Kids got their fingers and hair stuck, causing tears and mild injuries. Mattel removed it after numerous parent complaints and media coverage.

9. Easy-Bake Oven (2007 version)

JGKlein on Wikimedia

This classic oven’s redesign proved dangerous. Kids got fingers stuck in the opening, some resulting in burns and even one partial amputation. Hasbro issued a recall after nearly 250 incidents were reported.

10. Lawn Darts (Banned in 1988)

RDNE Stock project on Pexels

Lawn darts were a popular backyard game until they started causing serious injuries. The heavy, sharp-tipped darts were linked to multiple head injuries and even a child’s death. They were officially banned in the U.S. due to the danger.

11. Battlestar Galactica Missile Firing Toys (1978)

Kindel Media on Pexels

A toy spaceship from the TV series fired small plastic missiles that posed a choking hazard. After a boy tragically died from one, the toy was recalled. This led to new safety regulations for projectile toys.

12. Yo-Yo Water Balls (2003)

cottonbro studio on Pexels

These stretchy, squishy balls were connected to elastic cords and swung like yo-yos. Reports of them wrapping around children’s necks led to strangulation risks. Several countries banned them due to safety concerns.

13. Sky Rangers Park Flyer Radio-Controlled Airplane (2007)

Max Chen on Pexels

These RC planes could explode mid-flight due to battery overheating. A few incidents led to burns and melted plastic. The product was pulled quickly after the risks became clear.

14. Mini Hammocks (1996)

Ksenia Chernaya on Pexels

Marketed as relaxing fun for kids, these mini hammocks lacked spreader bars and became death traps. Multiple children became entangled and suffocated. After 12 deaths, the hammocks were recalled and banned from sale.

15. Troll Doll with “Satanic” Chant (1990s)

Ellie Burgin on Pexels

A special edition Troll doll reportedly made strange noises when pressed. Parents claimed the sounds resembled chanting or whispering dark phrases. Whether real or imagined, public concern led to the doll’s quiet disappearance from shelves.