15 TV Characters We Thought Were Cool But Weren’t
These 15 TV characters were once seen as cool, but on closer look, their behavior, choices, or attitudes were far from admirable.
- Sophia Zapanta
- 5 min read
Television has often shaped how people view what it means to be cool. Some characters stood out at the time, but over the years, their flaws became more obvious. This list reviews TV characters whose reputations no longer match their actual on-screen behavior.
1. Zack Morris – Saved by the Bell
Super Festivals on Wikimedia Commons
Zack was known as the charming class clown and leader of the group. He constantly broke rules, manipulated others, and avoided real consequences. Many episodes show him lying, cheating, or using people for personal gain. Rewatching the series reveals that his actions often lacked accountability and respect for others.
2. J.D. – Scrubs
David Shankbone on Wikimedia Commons
J.D. was quirky, smart, and the show’s narrator, which made him feel relatable. But his relationships often showed immaturity, selfishness, and a need for constant validation. He treated friends and romantic partners inconsistently. What seemed charming now appears emotionally manipulative at times.
3. Carrie Bradshaw – Sex and the City
David Shankbone on Wikimedia Commons
Carrie was seen as stylish and independent, but her decisions often hurt the people closest to her. She lacked self-awareness and handled relationships poorly. She judged others while excusing her own behavior. Her character often avoided growth despite many chances.
4. Tony Stark – Iron Man: Armored Adventures / MCU TV Tie-ins
Paul Bird on Wikimedia Commons
While more known for movies, Tony appeared in multiple animated series and tie-in shows. He was seen as a genius and a leader, but his arrogance and reckless decisions often endangered others. He dismissed advice and pushed his own ideas, even when wrong. His charm covered a pattern of selfish behavior.
5. Don Draper – Mad Men
Dominick D on Wikimedia Commons
Don was marketed as smooth and successful, but his life was built on deception. He lied about his identity, cheated in relationships, and treated people as disposable. His leadership came with emotional distance and poor personal ethics. Over time, his behavior seemed more harmful than admirable.
6. Serena van der Woodsen – Gossip Girl
Georges Biard on Wikimedia Commons
Serena was portrayed as the effortlessly cool girl, but her actions often contradicted that image. She was inconsistent, impulsive, and often placed herself above others. Her personal dramas affected those around her. The show revealed that charm does not equal depth or reliability.
7. Ryan Atwood – The O.C.
Peabody Awards on Wikimedia Commons
Ryan was the outsider turned hero, but many of his problems were due to poor choices. He often responded to conflict with violence or silence. While he tried to change, he rarely took responsibility in meaningful ways. His appeal came more from pity than from real growth.
8. Jess Mariano – Gilmore Girls
Toglenn on Wikimedia Commons
Jess was the bad boy love interest with a love for books. His attitude, however, was dismissive, rude, and emotionally closed off. He often left situations instead of facing them. What seemed mysterious in youth now reads as emotionally unavailable and immature.
9. Vincent Chase – Entourage
David Shankbone on Wikimedia Commons
Vincent was painted as relaxed and charming, but he lacked drive and self-control. His success came mostly from others managing his problems. He rarely showed leadership or growth throughout the series. The show exposed how little substance was behind the celebrity image.
10. Eric Cartman – South Park
mark6mauno on Wikimedia Commons
Cartman was seen as outrageous and bold, but much of his behavior was cruel and offensive. He regularly manipulated friends and caused harm for his own amusement. While intended as satire, some fans misread him as a rebel. His actions were extreme and dangerous, not clever or cool.
11. Barney Stinson – How I Met Your Mother
vagueonthehow on Wikimedia Commons
Barney was designed as the funny ladies’ man of the group. He often treated women as objects and lied to them regularly. His relationships were based on tricks, not honesty. Over time, his charm faded under repeated examples of disrespect.
12. Chuck Bass – Gossip Girl
Greg Hernandez on Wikimedia Commons
Chuck was once shown as wealthy and mysterious, but early seasons revealed deeply problematic behavior. He tried to assault multiple characters and used his power to manipulate others. The show later tried to redeem him, but the early actions remained serious. His romantic image was built on harmful traits.
13. Sheldon Cooper – The Big Bang Theory
iDominick on Wikimedia Commons
Sheldon was praised for being brilliant and unique, but he often ignored boundaries and insulted others. He showed little empathy and rarely admitted fault. His behavior was written off as quirky, though it impacted friends negatively. His intelligence did not excuse his lack of social awareness.
14. Michael Scott – The Office
Montclair Film Festival on Wikimedia Commons
Michael was often seen as a funny and lovable boss, but his behavior regularly crossed professional and personal lines. He made inappropriate jokes, showed favoritism, and lacked basic leadership skills. His employees often felt uncomfortable, disrespected, or overlooked. While he had good intentions at times, his actions frequently caused harm in the workplace.
15. BoJack Horseman – BoJack Horseman
Joanbanjo on Wikimedia Commons
BoJack was complex and relatable to some, but he caused harm to nearly everyone close to him. He struggled with addiction and trauma but refused help or change for much of the series. His choices hurt others over and over. The show itself acknowledges that being damaged does not make someone good.