15 Vintage Sports Memorabilia That’s Now Collectible
This list highlights 15 vintage sports memorabilia items that have become valuable and sought-after collectibles.
- Daisy Montero
- 5 min read
Old sports memorabilia can be worth a lot today. From trading cards to autographed gear, these pieces are now prized by collectors. Each item holds a story tied to a moment in sports history. This list shows which ones are now worth keeping an eye on.
1. 1952 Mickey Mantle Rookie Card
Bowman on Wikimedia Commons
The 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card is considered the crown jewel of sports cards. Its limited production and the legend behind the player make it a dream find for collectors. In pristine condition, this card has sold for over $12 million, making it a true blue-chip collectible.
2. Game-Worn Michael Jordan Finals Jersey
Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY via Imagn Content Services, LLC
Jordan’s jersey from the 1998 NBA Finals — often called “The Last Dance” — is one of the most iconic basketball collectibles in existence. The jersey sold for more than $10 million, showing how valuable game-worn gear can be. Fans see it as a piece of basketball history they can actually own.
3. Sandy Koufax Signed Baseball at the Elliott Museum
CRYSTAL VANDER WEIT/TCPALM / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
A signed Sandy Koufax ball is a standout in the Elliott Museum’s collection. The museum also features memorabilia from the Major Leagues, Negro Leagues, and the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League. It offers a wide view of baseball history through rare and meaningful items.
4. Hank Aaron Signed Photograph
Arturo Pardavila III from Hoboken, NJ, USA on Wikimedia Commons
A signed photo of Hank Aaron captures both the player and the moment. His signature adds value, especially when paired with an iconic action shot. Collectors prize these images for their timeless connection to baseball history.
5. Historic Game Ticket Stub
Pittalum on Wikimedia Commons
Ticket stubs from legendary games, like a World Series clincher or a player’s debut — hold surprising value. Even torn or creased, they remind fans of moments that changed sports history. Collectors often frame them or pair them with other memorabilia to achieve a full storytelling effect.
6. Felt Pennants from the 1960s–70s
Missouri Historical Society on Wikimedia Commons
Vintage felt pennants once waved in stadiums and bedrooms alike, showing pride for teams of the past. Their bold graphics and retro colors make them great display pieces today. Many collectors hunt for rare championship versions or those tied to defunct teams.
7. Game-Used Gloves or Bats
CRYSTAL VANDER WEIT/TCPALM / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
There is something powerful about holding a bat or glove used in a real game by a pro athlete. These items often show signs of wear — pine tar, dirt, or scuff marks — that connect them to the field. When authenticated, they become unique historical artifacts.
8. Sealed Wax Packs or Complete Sets
Erik Mclean on Pexels
Unopened wax packs from the ’70s or ’80s are like time capsules — you never know what’s inside. If they contain rookie cards or printing errors, they could be worth a small fortune. Complete vintage card sets also attract attention from collectors who want the full picture of an era.
9. Original Sports Magazines or Programs
Jennifer Eberbach/Livingston Daily / USA TODAY NETWORK
Old magazines and programs featuring legendary players in their prime offer a glimpse into how sports were once celebrated. These often include vintage ads, rosters, and early write-ups that add historical charm. First appearances of stars or event-specific editions are especially collectible.
10. Autographed Boxing Gloves
Albert Cesare/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK
Boxing gloves signed by champions like Muhammad Ali or Joe Louis feel raw and authentic. Unlike cards or prints, these are tied directly to the sport’s physicality. Their uniqueness and scarcity make them favorites among fight fans and sports collectors alike.
11. Game-Worn Uniforms or Jerseys
Ben Grieco/bgrieco@gannett.com / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
A real jersey worn during a big game connects fans to unforgettable moments in sports history. Each stitch and stain tells part of a story — whether it is a championship win or a rookie season. These items often include authentication tags or certificates that boost their value.
12. Vintage Promotional Bobbleheads
Patrick Breen/The Republic / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
Promotional bobbleheads from the ’50s and ’60s were once cheap giveaways but are now quirky collectibles. Their handmade feel, retro designs, and nods to specific teams make them highly collectible. Rarer models in good shape can fetch hundreds or even thousands.
13. Matched Ticket Bundles or Signed Stubs
MATT DAYHOFF/JOURNAL STAR / USA TODAY NETWORK
When stubs are collected from an entire playoff series or tied to a legendary player’s career, they become more meaningful. Signed versions add another level of rarity and value. Collectors often seek full narrative sets that tell a larger story.
14. Graded Rookie Cards in Gem Mint Condition
Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Rookie cards are already sought-after, but ones graded “gem mint” by PSA or Beckett command the highest prices. These cards look as if they just came off the printing press, even decades later. Their pristine condition makes them rare and highly desirable.
15. Vintage Sports Posters or Promotional Artwork
Paul Kuehnel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
Old posters promoting boxing matches, Super Bowls, or Olympic events are visually striking and full of cultural history. They blend art, advertising, and athletic pride in one collectible piece. Many fans frame these for their bold designs and nostalgic pull.