16 Shows Everyone Pretended to Like
We all know shows that seemed impossible not to watch or like, whether because of hype or sheer popularity. Yet, behind many enthusiastic endorsements lies a quiet truth — plenty of viewers were only pretending to enjoy them.
- Tricia Quitales
- 6 min read
Television has a way of creating shared experiences, even when some shows fall flat for many viewers. Sometimes a show becomes popular or critically acclaimed, yet a surprising number of people quietly dislike it. Social pressure, fear of missing out, or simply wanting to fit in leads many to pretend they enjoy certain series. Exploring these shows reveals how cultural phenomena can mask personal tastes and highlight the complexity of audience reception.
1. Friends
National Broadcasting Company (NBC) on Wikimedia
Undoubtedly a television giant, “Friends” became a cultural touchstone throughout the 1990s and beyond. Despite its massive fanbase, many viewers found the humor repetitive and the characters frustrating. Social situations often made people claim they loved every episode, even when they felt differently. The show’s relentless popularity made it difficult to admit disinterest. Its influence on pop culture is undeniable, but private opinions vary widely.
2. The Big Bang Theory
CBS on Wikimedia
This sitcom about a group of socially awkward scientists dominated prime time for years. While it earned strong ratings, some audiences criticized its stereotypical jokes and laugh track. Many felt pressured to enjoy it because of its success and awards. Public admiration often masked personal boredom or annoyance. It became a prime example of a show that split viewers between genuine fans and polite pretenders.
3. How I Met Your Mother
self on Wikimedia
Famous for its storytelling style and quirky characters, this show inspired strong devotion. Still, several fans grew tired of drawn-out plotlines and controversial finales. Admitting dissatisfaction was tricky since it had a passionate following. Group discussions often hid personal disappointment behind enthusiasm. Its popularity sometimes overshadowed honest opinions.
4. Gossip Girl
Gossip Girl/The CW on Wikimedia
The glamorous lives of Manhattan’s elite captivated viewers, but some found the drama over-the-top and the characters unrelatable. Social media buzz encouraged many to watch and praise it publicly. Behind closed doors, opinions ranged from mild enjoyment to complete indifference. Pretending to like it became part of joining in with cultural conversations. The show’s impact on fashion and teen culture was undeniable.
5. The Office (U.S.)
Jo9100 on Wikimedia
While hailed as a comedy classic, the show’s awkward humor was not for everyone. Some viewers struggled with the cringe style and uneven character development. Because of its critical acclaim, admitting dislike could feel like going against the crowd. The fanbase was vocal, but not always representative of all viewers’ feelings. It became a show many felt obligated to praise.
6. Jersey Shore
cottonbro studio on pexels
This reality TV phenomenon drew huge ratings but polarized viewers. Many pretended to enjoy the outrageous behavior and drama to stay in the loop. The cultural impact of the cast’s catchphrases and antics made it difficult to be honest about disliking it. Peer pressure and curiosity contributed to the show’s notoriety. Behind the scenes, opinions were far from unanimous.
7. Two and a Half Men
Warner Bros. Television Studios on Wikimedia
Long-running and widely watched, this sitcom had its share of criticism for repetitive humor and character changes. Some viewers publicly embraced the show while privately finding it stale. Its success created an environment where admitting boredom was awkward. The departure of key actors shifted opinions further. It became a program many tolerated rather than truly enjoyed.
8. Modern Family
ABC on Wikimedia
Acclaimed for its portrayal of diverse family dynamics, the show earned several awards and praise. Yet, some audiences found its style formulaic and emotionally manipulative. Social acceptance made it hard to express lukewarm feelings. Many watched to remain part of cultural conversations rather than out of genuine enthusiasm. It remains a show with mixed private reactions.
9. The Kardashians
Hulu on Wikimedia
The reality show about the famous family dominated pop culture but invited criticism for its superficiality. Fans and critics alike often talked about it as a guilty pleasure. Many viewers claimed interest for social reasons more than personal enjoyment. The show’s influence on beauty and lifestyle trends was enormous. It sparked conversations about fame and media influence.
10. House of Cards
Netflix on Wikimedia
This political drama received high praise for its writing and performances. However, some viewers found it slow-paced and overly cynical. Public perception often suggested universal admiration, though many quietly lost interest. Its intensity was polarizing, creating divides between critics and casual watchers. Pretending to like it was common in professional circles.
11. Lost
American Broadcasting Company on Wikimedia
Known for its mystery and complex storytelling, “Lost” captured millions of viewers. Still, the confusing plot and unsatisfying conclusion left some disappointed. Fans were vocal, but others felt the show was overrated. Group enthusiasm sometimes pressured viewers into silence about their frustrations. It highlighted the challenges of managing expectations.
12. Breaking Bad
AMC on Wikimedia
Praised as one of the greatest dramas ever, it set high standards for storytelling. Despite this, some viewers disliked its dark themes and slow buildup. The show’s critical acclaim made expressing dislike socially risky. Many nodded in approval without full engagement. It became a must-watch that divided audiences.
13. The Bachelor
RTL on Wikimedia
Popular reality dating show format sparked intense fandom and criticism. Many pretended to enjoy the drama and romance to join conversations. Behind the scenes, the formulaic nature was a common complaint. The show’s cultural footprint is vast despite mixed genuine interest. It thrives on spectacle rather than authentic connection.
14. Game of Thrones (Final Seasons)
Home Box Office, Inc. on Wikimedia
Early seasons won praise for epic storytelling and character depth. Later seasons, especially the finale, disappointed many long-term fans. Public discussion sometimes downplayed criticism to avoid spoilers or controversy. The passionate fanbase made dissenting opinions harder to voice. It serves as a cautionary tale about expectations and endings.
15. Fuller House
Jeff Franklin Productions and Miller-Boyett Productions on Wikimedia
The sequel to a beloved family sitcom drew nostalgia but mixed reactions. Some viewers watched to recapture childhood memories despite finding the new episodes weak. Expressing disapproval was tricky because of the original show’s fond place in hearts. It struggled to balance legacy with fresh storytelling. Many quietly admitted it did not live up to the original.
16. Dancing with the Stars
ABC on Wikimedia
This celebrity dance competition remains a staple in entertainment. Though ratings are steady, some find it repetitive and lacking genuine excitement. Social enthusiasm encourages viewers to appear interested. The format’s predictability makes it an easy show to pretend to enjoy. It remains a fixture in popular culture regardless.