17 Book Fair Purchases You Regret

Nostalgia for school book fairs often brings a smile, but not every purchase aged well. While some finds became treasured reads, others were more about shiny covers or novelty appeal than lasting value. From gimmicky gadgets to oddly specific reference books, these regretful buys were more shelf-fillers than page-turners. Looking back, it’s easy to see why some choices were more thrill than thought.

1. 1. The Poster Book

Glossy pages filled with photos of puppies, celebrities, or race cars were irresistible at the moment. Once you pulled them out, they were hard to hang without damaging them. Many ended up wrinkled or forgotten in a drawer. The quality rarely matched the excitement. It was more about having something cool to carry than a lasting keepsake.

2. 2. Joke Books

At first glance, a book filled with jokes seemed like the best way to impress friends. However, the humor was often corny or recycled from other sources. After a few reads, the novelty wore off quickly. The pages started to feel repetitive and dull. Most ended up gathering dust rather than laughs.

3. 3. Eraser Collections

Miniature erasers shaped like animals, food, or glittery stars were cute but barely functional. They smeared more than they erased, which made them useless in actual schoolwork. Still, they were often marketed as must-haves. Their charm faded quickly, especially when they broke in half or lost their scent. It was more toy than tool.

4. 4. The “Choose Your Own Adventure” Knockoffs

While the original series had some storytelling charm, the cheaper versions lacked depth. Choices led to abrupt or confusing endings, often without much logic. The writing felt rushed and repetitive. Many readers gave up halfway through. It was a letdown compared to the excitement promised on the cover.

5. 5. Sticker Books That Never Stuck

These books boasted reusable or collectible stickers, but reality often didn’t match the claims. The stickers peeled up at the corners or wouldn’t adhere at all. Once removed, they lost their stick entirely. The artwork was often low quality. You were left with blank pages and disappointment.

6. 6. Diaries with Fake Locks

A sparkly diary with a tiny key felt like the ultimate private treasure. However, the locks were flimsy and popped open with minimal effort. Anyone with a bobby pin could crack them. The paper was thin, and the covers wore out fast. It felt more like a prop than a place to hold your secrets.

7. 7. Puzzle Books That Were Way Too Hard

Some puzzle books looked fun and colorful but turned out to be far too difficult for their intended age. Word searches had impossible words, and mazes took hours to solve. It felt more like homework than fun. Frustration replaced the excitement quickly. Most were abandoned before the halfway point.

8. 8. Spin-Offs of Popular Series

Publishers jumped at the chance to milk successful franchises, and you were the eager customer. These books often lacked the voice, pacing, or creativity of the originals. They read more like fan fiction than official stories. Disappointment was almost guaranteed. The magic of the series was often missing entirely.

9. 9. Overpriced Bookmarks

Glittery bookmarks with tassels, 3D effects, or quotes seemed like a perfect add-on. However, they were fragile, bent easily, and got lost just as fast. Some cost as much as a paperback. The practical value rarely matched the price. A folded receipt worked better and lasted longer.

10. 10. “How-To Draw” Books You Never Mastered

These promised to turn you into an artist, one simple step at a time. However, the steps jumped from basic shapes to full figures too quickly. Without guidance, the results were discouraging. Many kids gave up after a few failed sketches. It was an optimistic purchase that didn’t deliver.

11. 11. Scratch-and-Sniff Books That Lost Scent Instantly

The idea of books you could smell was oddly thrilling in childhood. Unfortunately, the scent patches faded after one or two uses. Some didn’t even smell good to begin with. Once the smell was gone, so was the interest. It became just another picture book with missing magic.

12. 12. Trivia Books About Obscure Topics

Books filled with facts about topics like ancient tools or rare birds looked smart at first. However, they were often too niche to hold attention. Most facts were too specific to remember or reuse. The text felt dry and overly serious. They rarely left a lasting impression.

13. 13. Tiny Novels with Tiny Print

Some books had hundreds of pages crammed into a pocket-sized format with unreadable fonts. Reading them felt more like squinting at a phone screen. The physical discomfort outweighed any joy from the story. They were hard to carry and harder to finish. Convenience became a burden.

14. 14. Activity Books with Missing Pieces

Anything with pop-outs, punch-outs, or included accessories was a gamble. Often, something was torn, missing, or never included. That ruined the whole point of the book. Returning it was rarely an option. It felt like paying for disappointment in paper form.

15. 15. Books About Fads That Didn’t Last

Titles about Tamagotchis, slap bracelets, or other passing crazes felt cool in the moment. However, once the fad faded, so did your interest. The book quickly felt outdated and irrelevant. The writing was often rushed to match the trend’s timing. It had a short shelf life in every sense.

16. 16. Glitter-Covered Notebooks You Never Used

Sparkly notebooks with unicorns or holographic effects looked amazing on the table. However, many were too pretty to write in, or the glitter flaked off constantly. Some pages were oddly shaped or poor quality. They sat unused on desks and shelves. It was more decoration than function.

17. 17. Novelty Pens That Barely Worked

Pens that lit up, changed color, or had floating glitter felt irresistible. However, they ran out of ink fast or didn’t write smoothly. Often, the mechanism broke within days. They were more fun to look at than to use. Ultimately, they ended up in the trash instead of your pencil case.

• Tags:
• book fairs
• book purchases
• regretful buys
• school fairs