17 Store Brands That Were Better Than Name Brands
These 17 store-brand products defied expectations by outperforming name brands in taste, quality, and value.
- Alyana Aguja
- 5 min read
Store brands were once considered the cheaper, lower-quality alternative, but these 17 examples prove otherwise. From Trader Joe’s iconic snacks to Kirkland’s high-performing household staples, consumers consistently found better value without compromising on taste or performance. These products show that sometimes the best choice on the shelf isn’t the most expensive, but the one with the store label.
1. Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter Filled Pretzels
Image from Wikipedia
Trader Joe’s made a quiet snack revolution with their Peanut Butter Filled Pretzels. Unlike many brand-name versions that tasted stale or overly salty, these had the perfect crunch and creamy peanut butter inside. They became a cult favorite for their quality, price, and addictive flavor.
2. Kirkland Signature Batteries (Costco)
Image from Wikipedia
Kirkland Signature batteries often outlasted Duracell or Energizer in performance tests. Regular Costco shoppers quickly caught on and started bulk-buying them for their electronics. The value-to-performance ratio was unbeatable, saving families a lot of money in the long run.
3. Aldi’s Choceur Chocolate
Image from Wikipedia
Aldi’s private label Choceur Chocolate is made in Europe and rivals brands like Lindt in taste and texture. Smooth, rich, and surprisingly affordable, it became a hidden gem for chocolate lovers. People were shocked at how luxurious it felt for such a low price.
4. Great Value Macaroni & Cheese (Walmart)
Image from Wikipedia
Great Value’s mac and cheese had a loyal following for its creamy texture and satisfying flavor. Many kids preferred it over Kraft due to its cheesier punch and better texture when cooked right. Parents especially loved it for the price and convenience during busy weeknights.
5. Target’s Good & Gather Organic Salsa
Image from Wikipedia
Good & Gather’s Organic Salsa from Target delivered fresh taste without the price tag of premium name brands. It had a chunky texture and bold flavor that rivaled more expensive organic salsas. Even salsa snobs were impressed by its clean ingredients and depth.
6. 365 by Whole Foods Market Almond Butter
Image from Wikipedia
Whole Foods’ 365 Almond Butter gained popularity for its pure ingredient list and smooth consistency. Compared to pricier name-brand versions with added oils or sugars, 365’s option was a healthier, tastier pick. It blended easily into smoothies or spread perfectly on toast.
7. Trader Joe’s Mandarin Orange Chicken
Image from Wikipedia
Trader Joe’s Mandarin Orange Chicken became legendary for its restaurant-quality flavor. People swore it was better than takeout, with crispy chicken and a tangy sauce that hit all the right notes. It was consistently voted a fan favorite in Trader Joe’s annual polls.
8. Kirkland Signature Vodka (Costco)
Image from Wikipedia
Rumors swirled that Kirkland Vodka was sourced from the same place as Grey Goose. Whether or not it’s true, the vodka consistently performed well in blind taste tests. It delivered smooth sips at a fraction of the cost, making it a staple for budget-conscious cocktail lovers.
9. Aldi’s Millville Cereals
Image from Wikipedia
Millville, Aldi’s in-house cereal brand, makes spot-on replicas of big-name favorites like Cheerios and Frosted Flakes. Often made in the same factories, the taste was nearly identical but at half the price. Parents didn’t mind the plain boxes once the kids stopped complaining.
10. Target’s Up & Up Diapers
Image from Wikipedia
Parents on a budget found that Target’s Up & Up diapers held up better than some premium brands. They were durable, absorbent, and gentle on baby skin. With fewer leaks and rashes, families kept coming back for more.
11. Wegmans Pasta Sauce
Image from Wikipedia
Wegmans’ store-brand pasta sauce tasted like it came from a family-run Italian restaurant. Rich, herby, and slow-simmered, it rivaled premium jars like Rao’s without breaking the bank. People who once avoided store-brand sauces became instant converts.
12. Trader Joe’s Everything But the Bagel Seasoning
Image from Wikipedia
This spice blend became a viral hit and inspired countless copycats. Trader Joe’s nailed the perfect mix of sesame, garlic, onion, and salt, turning plain eggs or avocado toast into gourmet fare. Name-brand spice companies rushed to follow suit, but few matched the original’s flavor.
13. Kirkland Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Image from Wikipedia
Costco’s olive oil is frequently praised for being authentic, cold-pressed, and tested for purity. It’s often recommended by chefs and food experts for its smooth taste and quality. At a lower price point than imported bottles, it became a pantry staple for serious home cooks.
14. Aldi’s Friendly Farms Greek Yogurt
Image from Wikipedia
Friendly Farms’ Greek Yogurt from Aldi shocked people with its creamy consistency and clean ingredients. It tasted just as good, if not better, than Chobani or Fage at a lower price. The flavored versions especially hit the mark for a quick protein-packed snack.
15. Publix Premium Ice Cream
Image from Wikipedia
Publix’s Premium Ice Cream is a Southern secret that’s slowly gaining nationwide fame. Creamy, rich, and available in inventive flavors, it often outperformed brands like Breyers or Häagen-Dazs in taste tests. Locals swear by it, especially the Southern-inspired varieties like Peach Cobbler.
16. Great Value Paper Towels (Walmart)
Image from Wikipedia
Great Value Paper Towels surprised customers with their strength and absorbency. They held up to tough messes just as well as Bounty but at a lower price per roll. Budget-conscious shoppers found no reason to go back to name brands.
17. Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup
Image from Wikipedia
Kirkland’s Organic Maple Syrup is 100% pure and Grade A, competing easily with expensive artisanal brands. It pours smoothly, tastes rich, and doesn’t have the watered-down feel of many mass-market versions. For breakfast lovers, it’s a no-brainer pick.