20 Discontinued Candies You’d Do Anything to Taste Again
Not all candies are meant to last forever, even the ones we loved the most. These discontinued classics still live rent-free in our minds and taste buds, no matter how long it's been since their last appearance.
- Tricia Quitales
- 7 min read
Some candies disappear from shelves without warning, leaving only memories of their unique flavor and the occasional fan petition. They were more than just sweets; they were part of childhood, road trips, movie nights, and school lunches. Whether pulled for low sales, changing trends, or ingredient concerns, these treats left behind a serious craving. If they ever returned, there would be a stampede to the nearest checkout line.
1. Butterfinger BB’s
Evan-Amos on Wikimedia
These little round bites had all the crispiness of a classic Butterfinger, but in a fun poppable form. They were perfect for sharing, though most people kept them to themselves. Their chocolate coating didn’t melt as fast as the bar, which made them ideal movie snacks. Fans still mourn their disappearance from theaters and shelves. They were discontinued in the mid-2000s with no real explanation.
2. PB Max
wutthichai charoenburi on pexels
With peanut butter, oats, and a thick chocolate coating, PB Max was a dream for peanut butter lovers. Mars discontinued it, claiming the family just didn’t like peanut butter. That reason confused millions who couldn’t get enough of the bar’s rich, crunchy bite. Its texture set it apart from other candy bars. People still hope for a surprise comeback.
3. Reggie! Bar
Pervane Mustafa27 on Pexels
Named after baseball legend Reggie Jackson, this circular treat packed caramel, peanuts, and chocolate into one bold bite. It launched in the 1970s and had a short revival in the ’90s. The bar was heavy and satisfying, with a fan base of both candy lovers and sports fans. It stood out thanks to its name and unique marketing. Sadly, it’s now just a nostalgic memory.
4. Wonka Donutz
Amanda Hemphill on Pexels
These chocolatey donut-shaped treats were filled with gooey cream and covered in sprinkles. Packaged like tiny desserts, they felt more like pastries than candy. Kids loved them for their playful shape and sweet center. They were part of the larger Wonka candy universe that disappeared over time. Today, they’re a collector’s memory item on resale sites.
5. Bar None
Polina Tankilevitch on Pexels
Bar None was Nestlé’s attempt to create a chocolate bar that “tamed the chocolate beasty.” It had layers of wafer, chocolate cream, and a thick chocolate coating. Fans praised it for being rich and deeply chocolatey without being too sweet. It had a unique texture that set it apart. After being rebranded and altered, it quietly vanished from shelves.
6. Swoops
ROMAN ODINTSOV on Pexels
Shaped like potato chips but made entirely of chocolate, Swoops came in flavors like peanut butter and mint. The design made them easy to snack on, but also fragile. They melted quickly in your fingers, which made them fun and slightly messy. People appreciated their portion control and novelty. Despite popularity, they were discontinued in 2006.
7. Life Savers Holes
Eva Bronzini on Pexels
Meant to be the center “holes” from traditional Life Savers, these small candies were marketed in fun pop-top containers. They were fruity, flavorful, and easy to snack on. Parents liked that they were less of a choking hazard. Unfortunately, a packaging recall led to their removal. Fans still talk about how fun they were to eat.
8. Hershey’s S’Mores Bar
yazz davis on pexels
This candy bar combined graham cracker bits, marshmallow crème, and chocolate in a single bite. It tasted like a campfire without the smoke. It was a hit during the summer months and brought back warm childhood memories. For some reason, Hershey’s never made it permanent. Many still search for similar alternatives today.
9. Marathon Bar
willsantt on Pexels
A twisty rope of chocolate-covered caramel, the Marathon Bar stretched to almost a foot in length. It came with a ruler printed on the package to show off its size. Its chewy texture made it last longer than most candy bars. Known in the UK as Curly Wurly, the U.S. version disappeared in the 1980s. It remains a favorite among nostalgic candy fans.
10. Seven Up Bar
Polina Tankilevitch on pexels
This unique bar had seven different flavor-filled squares, from nougat to cherry to coconut. Each section was a surprise, which made it fun to eat slowly. People loved the mix of textures and flavors in a single candy. It was discontinued in the 1970s and has never had a proper replacement. Fans still remember it as one of the most creative candy bars ever made.
11. Topp’s Juice Bar Gum
Ketut Subiyanto on Pexels
This chewing gum came in a bar-shaped wrapper and oozed with juicy filling when bitten. It was colorful, bold, and packed with fruity flavor. Kids loved the burst of juice even though it didn’t last long. It felt like a combination of candy and gum. Eventually, it faded from popularity and was pulled from stores.
12. Reese’s Bites
Evan-Amos on Wikimedia
These tiny, round versions of Reese’s Cups were a hit in the early 2000s. They offered the perfect ratio of peanut butter and chocolate in a bite-sized form. Easy to eat by the handful, they were popular with both kids and adults. They disappeared quietly without a clear reason. Some fans believe they were the best peanut butter snack ever made.
13. Nestlé Wonder Ball (with candy)
Anna Tarazevich on Pexels
The original version of the Wonder Ball had little candies inside instead of toys. Chocolate on the outside, surprise inside — it was like an edible mystery box. Parents loved the safer candy version more than the toy version. It was discontinued, brought back, then changed entirely. The candy-filled version is still the most missed.
14. Summit Bar
Ahmad Tawfik on pexels
With layers of wafer and peanuts, the Summit Bar was crunchy, rich, and surprisingly lightweight. It came in a long rectangular shape that made it stand out. Its combination of salt and sweet was ahead of its time. People loved the satisfying texture contrast. It quietly disappeared in the late ’80s.
15. Buttercream Mints
Darlene Alderson on Pexels
These soft, melt-in-your-mouth mints had a smooth and creamy interior with a slight crunch outside. Often wrapped in pastel colors, they were common at weddings and in grandma’s candy dish. The flavor was mild and comforting. They weren’t flashy, but they were beloved by those who remembered them. Now, they’re hard to find except in specialty shops.
16. Milkshake Bar
solod_sha on Pexels
The Milkshake Bar was designed to taste like a creamy milkshake in chocolate bar form. It had a thick, chewy texture that made it different from other candies. It came in several flavors, including vanilla and strawberry. Fans appreciated the nostalgic diner-inspired vibe. Sadly, it didn’t stick around for long.
17. Bonkers! Fruit Chews
SHVETS production on Pexels
These chewy square candies came with a fruity burst in the center. Ads were loud and zany, and the candy matched the energy. Kids loved the explosive taste and playful packaging. Bonkers were phased out in the 1990s with a few failed comebacks. Still, many people would grab a pack today if they saw it on shelves.
18. Ouch! Bubble Gum
cottonbro studio on pexels
Shaped like bandages and packaged in a tiny metal tin, this bubble gum was an instant hit for its clever design. The flavors were fruity and strong, though the gum hardened fast. Kids loved the novelty of pulling out a “bandage” to chew. It was more about style than flavor. Eventually, it disappeared from the novelty gum scene.
19. Hershey’s Bar None
Tamanna Rumee on pexels
This bar has earned a second mention because many fans still talk about its original recipe. The original version was rich, chocolate-heavy, and had layers that worked perfectly. Its rebrand lost much of what people loved. Disappointment followed, and it never regained popularity. People still compare new bars to the original Bar None.
20. Tart ‘n’ Tinys
Katie Rainbow 🏳️🌈 on Pexels
Small, colorful candies with a tangy punch, Tart ‘n’ Tinys were crunchy and fun to pour by the handful. They were a hit in classrooms and lunchboxes. Over time, they were reformulated into chewy versions, losing their iconic crunch. The original hard version is what fans miss most. They were simple, but unforgettable.