20 Most Dominant College Athletes in History
These 20 legendary athletes didn’t just win in college — they overwhelmed the competition and rewrote the record books.
- Chris Graciano
- 4 min read
College sports have seen countless stars, but only a rare few truly redefined what dominance looks like. These athletes not only led their teams to victory but also crushed records, claimed awards, and left a legacy that still echoes in stadiums and arenas today. From football to gymnastics, here are 20 college athletes who were in a league of their own.
20. Sabrina Ionescu – Oregon (Basketball)
Stephen R. Sylvanie-Imagn Images
Ionescu is the NCAA’s all-time leader in triple-doubles, blending scoring, passing, and rebounding with ease. Her leadership and clutch play elevated Oregon into a powerhouse.
19. Logan Stieber – Ohio State (Wrestling)
Jeff Curry-Imagn Images
Stieber won four NCAA titles in four different weight classes — a rare and elite achievement. His adaptability and consistency made him a nightmare matchup.
18. Christian Laettner – Duke (Basketball)
The Courier-Journal-USA TODAY NETWORK
Love him or hate him, Laettner’s record speaks: four Final Fours, two titles, and one legendary buzzer-beater. His poise under pressure was unmatched. He was the villain who always came out on top.
17. Megan Rapinoe – Portland (Soccer)
Eric Hartline-Imagn Images
Before she became a global icon, Rapinoe was carving up college defenses with dazzling footwork and clutch plays. She helped Portland win a national title in 2005. Her flair and precision stood out early.
16. Marcus Allen – USC (Football)
Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images
Allen became the first player to rush for over 2,000 yards in a season, claiming the 1981 Heisman. He glided across the turf with patience and power. A back with vision and finesse.
15. Anthony Davis – Kentucky (Basketball)
Bob Donnan-Imagn Images
Davis was a defensive juggernaut, leading Kentucky to a national title in 2012 with insane block numbers and interior dominance. His wingspan altered every shot. He turned defense into an art form.
14. Maya Moore – UConn (Basketball)
Nicole Sweet-Imagn Images
Moore’s winning résumé includes two national championships, multiple Player of the Year awards, and a nearly perfect college record. She was unstoppable from anywhere on the court.
13. Cam Newton – Auburn (Football)
John Reed-Imagn Images
In 2010, Newton had one of the greatest seasons in college football history, winning the Heisman and leading Auburn to a national title. His dual-threat ability terrorized defenses.
12. Rachel Garcia – UCLA (Softball)
Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images
Garcia was a two-way threat, winning National Player of the Year twice while pitching and hitting at elite levels. She carried UCLA to a national championship in 2019. A true workhorse with ice in her veins.
11. Patrick Ewing – Georgetown (Basketball)
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
Ewing was the anchor of Georgetown’s intimidating defense, taking them to three title games and winning one. His shot-blocking altered every opponent’s plan. He patrolled the paint like a lion.
10. Cheryl Miller – USC (Basketball)
Long Photography-Imagn Images
A pioneer and phenom, Miller led USC to two national titles and dominated every stat sheet. She averaged over 23 points and 12 rebounds a game.
9. Tim Tebow – Florida (Football)
Jason Parkhurst-Imagn Images
Tebow’s passion, leadership, and physicality led the Gators to two national championships. He became the first sophomore to win the Heisman in 2007. His will to win was contagious.
8. Jenny Thompson – Stanford (Swimming)
George Long-Imagn Images
Thompson collected 19 NCAA titles and set multiple national records in the pool. She set the standard for collegiate swimming excellence. Her strokes were as smooth as they were deadly.
7. Pete Maravich – LSU (Basketball)
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
“Pistol” Pete averaged over 44 points per game, without the three-point line. His creativity and ball handling were decades ahead of their time. Every game was a show.
6. Lisa Fernandez – UCLA (Softball)
Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
A pitching and hitting powerhouse, Fernandez helped UCLA claim multiple national titles and posted a 93-7 career record. She could dominate a lineup from the circle or the batter’s box.
5. Barry Sanders – Oklahoma State (Football)
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
In 1988, Sanders rushed for over 2,600 yards in a single season, scoring 39 touchdowns and capturing the Heisman Trophy. His elusiveness was legendary. Defenders couldn’t touch him — he moved like smoke.
4. Cael Sanderson – Iowa State (Wrestling)
Matt Kryger-USA TODAY
Sanderson finished his college career undefeated at 159-0, winning four national championships. That record? Untouchable. He didn’t just win — he humiliated opponents.
3. Herschel Walker – Georgia (Football)
Manny Rubio-Imagn Images
As a freshman, Walker rushed for over 1,600 yards and never slowed down. He carried Georgia to a national title and a Heisman win in 1982. His strength, speed, and stamina were off the charts.
2. Breanna Stewart – UConn (Basketball)
Soobum Im-Imagn Images
Stewart led UConn to four straight national championships and earned four Final Four Most Outstanding Player honors. She made winning look routine. Every season felt like her personal highlight reel.
1. Bo Jackson – Auburn (Football/Baseball)
Manny Rubio-Imagn Images
Bo electrified crowds at Auburn with unmatched power and speed in both football and baseball. He won the 1985 Heisman Trophy and could break a game wide open in seconds. His dual-sport brilliance was simply unreal.