20 Popular School Lunch Foods From the 1970s That Vanished

In the 1970s, school lunches were robust, creative, and innovative, reflecting the tastes, budgets, and convenient food preparation of the time. From the pizza burger to tuna noodle casserole, Frito pie, and chicken à la King, school lunches were a fusion of comfort food, creativity, and practicality. These dishes, prepared using processed foods, creamy sauces, and sweet-savory flavors, were a hit among children while helping to stretch school budgets. However, over the years, the evolving face of school lunches, driven by new nutritional guidelines, allergy concerns, food costs, and student tastes, has transformed school lunches across the country.

1. Pizza Burgers

Pizza burgers were a staple on many cafeteria trays in the 1970s. These burgers were essentially a combination of ground beef, tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese on a hamburger bun. These were then put under the broiler to give the cheese on top a nice brown color and to ensure that the cheese stretched with each bite. These were the essence of Friday night pizza nights, even if they looked like they were meant for speed and efficiency. These were served in bulk by the lunch ladies and were often served with buttered corn and canned peaches. These were a favorite among students because they were a combination of Italian cuisine and American comfort food. However, these were eventually replaced due to new nutrition laws and changing tastes.

2. Salisbury Steak with Brown Gravy

Salisbury steak sat on split plastic trays, waiting to be served. It had a glossy brown gravy that pooled next to the mashed potatoes. The steaks were preformed, frozen, and then cooked in large metal ovens before serving. It was a hearty, mature dish, almost diner food in a school cafeteria setting. The cafeterias served it with green beans or carrots, making it look like a serious, adult meal. Students enjoyed the savory taste or toyed with it using a fork, depending on their preferences. As the standards of processed meats changed, so did the menu, favoring lighter dishes, and it disappeared from the menu over time.

3. Chili and Cinnamon Rolls

The combination of chili and cinnamon rolls may not seem to go together in a bowl or on a plate. Yet this combination took its place confidently in the Midwestern school cafeterias. The combination of spicy beef and beans was served in small bowls with a sweet cinnamon roll topped with icing. Students could dip their bread in the chili or eat the two dishes separately to make this strange yet beloved combination. The warmth of the chili and the sweetness of the cinnamon rolls were a comforting change on chilly days in school. Yet this strange combination was relegated to a rarity again as traditions were replaced with standardized foods.

4. Beefaroni Casserole

Beefaroni casserole came out of deep metal pans, with elbow macaroni and beef mixed with tomato sauce to make a thick and bubbling casserole. Sometimes the top layer was crispy on the outside, so that each serving had a soft center and crispy edges. Beefaroni casserole seemed a comforting and secure offering, one that could calm a loud cafeteria. Cafeteria staff served it with white bread and a carton of milk to make a simple and complete lunch. The sweetness of the tomato sauce helped to make this casserole popular with younger students. As the menu changed to feature healthier pasta dishes and nutrition guidelines, this thick casserole faded from the menu.

5. Tuna Noodle Casserole

The tuna noodle casserole combined egg noodles, tuna, and cream of mushroom soup, creating a pale and creamy dish topped with crushed potato chips. It baked into a soft, comforting square that held together just enough on a plastic tray. The saltiness of the chips complemented the mild taste of the filling. Some students recognized this dish immediately, as they had eaten it at home. For others, they avoided this dish due to the tuna smell, which lingered in the room. As students’ attitudes and tuna sources changed, this traditional dish disappeared.

6. Crumb

Turkey Tetrazzini consists of thin spaghetti, diced turkey, and white sauce, all topped with a faintly golden brown finish. The spaghetti twists and turns, creating a sophisticated scoop. It’s a more refined dish for a meal, unlike the simplicity of a school lunch. Its taste rests delicately on the tongue, neither strong nor overpowering. Schools served this dish after the holidays to use up leftover turkey, making it a convenient, homey dish. A sprinkle of fresh parsley adds a pop of color to the dull surface. However, as the years went on, the price of ingredients and the public’s taste buds led to newer, more contemporary variations.

7. Sloppy Joes

The Sloppy Joe was the king of the school lunches, with the sloppy, juicy mix of ground beef and sweet tomato-based sauce served on soft hamburger buns. Every time someone took a bite, the filling would ooze out, leaving the victim’s fingers and napkins stained. In the cafeterias, the mix was kept warm in big kettles, ready to be assembled quickly and simply. The taste was sweet and tangy, making the Sloppy Joe a surefire winner among the students. Chips or coleslaw would round out the meal, providing a nice contrast to the soft sandwich. However, as the debate on the content of sugar and processed meats heated up, the Sloppy Joe slowly disappeared from the school menu.

8. Corn Dogs on a Stick

Corn dogs on a stick added a carnival flair to school lunches in the 1970s. The dish featured a hot dog wrapped in a thick batter made of cornmeal and fried to a golden brown. The kids enjoyed eating this dish because of the fun of eating a sandwich on a stick and dipping the crunchy outside in either mustard or ketchup. The outside was crunchy, and the inside was soft and salty. As the fad of frying in school lunches came to an end and school lunches became healthier, this dish gradually disappeared.

9. Fish Sticks with Tartar Sauce

Fish sticks were arranged on serving trays in a row. These were breaded and then baked to give them a crisp exterior. These were served with a side of tartar sauce. For many students, this looked familiar because they were also found in the freezers in their homes. These were often served with peas or macaroni salad in the cafeterias. This was a seafood option that was mild in flavor but not liked by everyone because of the texture. However, over time, this was not served due to changes in the source and new guidelines.

10. Barbecue Beef on a Bun

The barbecue beef on a bun was served warm, with the shredded beef smothered in a thick, smoky sauce that was absorbed nicely into the soft roll. This sandwich was hearty and bold compared to the more bland cafeteria food. There was a pleasant sweetness and spice to the sandwich that lingered with every bite. Paper napkins seldom lasted more than the first few bites, as the sauce tended to leak out of the roll. Potato wedges or baked beans accompanied the meal on the lunch trays.

11. Frito Pie

Frito pie was a bag of corn chips taken and made into a complete meal with the addition of hot chili and cheese. Some cafeterias would open a bag of corn chips and pour the hot chili into the bag. The meal was ready and convenient. The corn chips were softened by the hot chili and still had a little crunch. It was a treat for the students with the salty and spicy taste all combined into one small package. It was a casual and fun meal, almost like a snack dressed up as a lunch. However, with concerns over the amount of salt and processed snacks, this meal was taken off the school lunch menus.

12. Creamed Chipped Beef on Toast

Creamed chipped beef on toast is a meal consisting of thin slices of dried beef mixed with a thick white sauce and served over square toast. The sauce slowly drips into the toast and soaks into the bread. This meal was simple to look at but offered a hearty and rich experience. Cafeterias made the most of their food supplies by cooking large quantities of creamed chipped beef on toast. This was a favorite meal for many students, especially on cold mornings when it was served as an early lunch. This meal slowly disappeared from school lunch menus as student tastes changed and school lunches became more diverse.

13. Ham and Cheese Foldovers

The ham and cheese foldovers resembled small calzones, filled with diced ham and melted American cheese inside a pizza dough. The crust was golden brown, giving a golden edge to the pizza. As one ate the pizza, the cheese stretched slightly before going back into the crust. Cafeterias used them because they were stackable, and students ate them because they were a taste that was half sandwich and half pizza. As frozen food and pizza became more advanced, these simple pizzas were no longer seen.

14. Chicken à la King over Rice

Chicken pieces cooked in a creamy sauce, served with green peas and pimentos, are liberally arranged atop a bed of white rice, where the sauce has gently bathed the individual grains of rice. It has a mild, buttery taste, making it easy to consume. It appears to be a home-cooked meal that was modified for the cafeteria setting by making it faster to serve by cooking it en masse in a large pan and holding it warm on a steam table. As the culinary tastes of the student body shifted towards grilled and seasoned chicken, this dish was phased out of the menu.

15. Peanut Butter and Honey Sandwiches

The peanut butter and honey sandwich originated as a solution to a problem when hot lunches were no longer readily available. Peanut butter spread thickly and topped with a drizzle of honey, which seeped into the white bread, proved to be a simple yet satisfying combination. The sweetness of the honey balanced out the saltiness of the peanut butter. These sandwiches were neatly packed in wax paper and accompanied by apple slices and a glass of milk. This sandwich was a welcome change for many students, reminiscent of a home-packed lunch. As peanut butter began to be banned due to peanut allergies, this sandwich gradually faded away.

16. Spanish Rice with Ground Beef

The Spanish dish made with rice, ground beef, and served in the steam table containers was a full meal. It was full of flavor, with the rice absorbing the flavors of the tomato sauce and the ground beef. There was a hint of green pepper, which gave the dish some color. This dish was popular among the cafeterias, as it was filling and lasted for a while. Its taste was on the lighter side, with a hint of spice that was not difficult for students to digest. However, as the menu became more focused on grain bowls, this dish slowly became a thing of the past.

17. Open-Faced Hot Turkey Sandwich with Gravy

Sliced white bread, cut thinly, provides a canvas for the hot turkey, piled high and topped with brown gravy. The gravy soaks into the bread, mixing with mashed potatoes served on the side. The dish was substantial, providing a sense of warmth and coziness during chilly days. The lunch staff would prep sliced turkey in advance and assemble the dish in a hurry during the lunch rush. Students used forks instead of their fingers to eat this dish, creating a quiet and civilized meal. As gravy mixes became less popular and leaner turkey options became available, this classic dish fell out of favor.

18. Stuffed Bell Peppers

Bell peppers, hollowed out and standing upright on trays, had a filling of ground beef and rice that was baked inside the peppers’ green exterior. A slight browning was evident on the top, providing a solid, whole bite to the filling. In the oven, the peppers became soft, and a slight sweetness was evident, providing balance to the filling. This dish was popular in cafeterias for its wholesome, filling nature. However, some students loved the filling, while others avoided the vegetable casing. Over the years, the process and the divided opinions led to the dish being removed from school menus.

19. Goulash with Elbow Macaroni

Goulash with elbow macaroni was used to fill the massive cafeteria pots with a thick and beefy tomato sauce. The macaroni noodles soaked up the seasoned mixture to produce a hearty flavor that was slightly sweet and seemed to be popular among the children. Cafeterias were known to serve this in abundance on a tray, along with a slice of white bread. This was a comforting and traditional dish during the busy days in school. However, with the change in menu to lighter and healthier options in pasta dishes, this traditional staple slowly disappeared from the menu.

20. Chocolate Pudding with Skin on Top

Chocolate pudding with that skin on top was a common feature of many lunches in the 1970s, a small serving of rich, thick pudding to finish off the meal. It sat in metal pans to set, then was divided into plastic cups for serving. As it cooled, a thin skin formed on top, making it a little firmer, a texture that some kids loved to peel off, while others did not. It was a rich, dense pudding, a depth of taste that seems to be lacking in much of the pudding available today. It was a cheap and easy food to serve in the cafeteria, but as packaged foods took over, it disappeared from the menu.

• Tags:
• throwback
• 1970s
• school lunch
• school life
• vanished lunch