20 Times Retired Athletes Tried Comebacks (Some Worked!)
In the world of sports, the thrill of competition often pulls athletes back to the game even after they’ve retired. Some retired athletes attempt comebacks driven by passion, unfinished business, or just the desire to relive their glory days. While some of these comebacks are successful, others fade quickly, reminding us that time may be the ultimate opponent.
- Tricia Quitales
- 7 min read
Retired athletes returning to their sport is not an uncommon occurrence, with many trying to recapture their past glory. Some make triumphant returns, while others struggle or fall short of expectations. In this article, we look at 20 such attempts, highlighting the successes and the failures. From iconic athletes like Michael Jordan to lesser-known figures, we explore the reasons behind their comebacks and how they fared when they tried to step back onto the field or court.
1. Michael Jordan (Basketball)
Pete Souza on Wikimedia
Michael Jordan’s return to the NBA in 1995 after his first retirement is one of the most famous comebacks in sports history. Jordan helped the Chicago Bulls to three more championships before retiring again in 1999. His second comeback in 2001 with the Washington Wizards was less successful, but it still captured the public’s imagination.
2. Tiger Woods (Golf)
The White House on Wikimedia
After a series of personal issues and injuries, Tiger Woods made an unexpected return to professional golf in 2018. His comeback was capped with a victory at the 2019 Masters, marking his 15th major title. Woods’ resilience and determination proved that even after setbacks, a legendary athlete can still find success.
3. Brett Favre (Football)
Chief Mass Communication Specialist Eric Durie, USN on Wikimedia
Brett Favre’s retirement and return to the NFL in 2008 shocked many, especially as he came back to play for the Minnesota Vikings after years with the Green Bay Packers. Favre had a strong season, leading the Vikings to the playoffs, but his later years were filled with controversies and struggles. His decision to return a second time, despite his age and injury history, was seen as a testament to his competitive spirit.
4. Andre Agassi (Tennis)
Xiaojeng~commonswiki on Wikimedia
Andre Agassi retired from tennis in 2006 after a stellar career, but his comeback at the 2006 U.S. Open was a huge moment. He made it to the third round, showing that his skills were still sharp despite his age. However, Agassi retired for good in 2007, deciding it was time to step away permanently.
5. Muhammad Ali (Boxing)
White House photo by Paul Morse on Wikimedia
Muhammad Ali’s boxing career saw several retirements and comebacks, the most notable being in 1970 when he was banned from the sport for refusing the draft. His successful return to the ring included winning the World Heavyweight Championship three times. Despite his decline in health in later years, Ali’s desire to return to boxing remained unwavering.
6. Lance Armstrong (Cycling)
Cpl. William Howard, Combat Aviation Brigade, 1st Infantry Division on Wikimedia
After being banned for doping, Lance Armstrong returned to cycling in 2009, competing in the Tour de France once more. While his comeback was filled with public scrutiny and questions about his integrity, Armstrong still managed to place highly in races. However, his career ended in disgrace after a doping scandal in 2012.
7. Shaquille O’Neal (Basketball)
Airman 1st Class Alex Gouchnour, U.S. Air Force on Wikimedia
Shaquille O’Neal’s return to basketball in 2009 with the Phoenix Suns was an attempt to win one more championship. However, O’Neal’s body had aged, and injuries took a toll on his performance. Despite this, his leadership and experience helped the Suns to a playoff appearance, but they were eliminated in the second round.
8. Martina Navratilova (Tennis)
Hans van Dijk for Anefo on Wikimedia
In 2000, Martina Navratilova, then 43, came out of retirement to compete in doubles and mixed doubles tournaments. She won several titles, proving that age was no barrier to her skill and competitive drive. However, despite her success, she ultimately decided to retire for good in 2003.
9. Tom Brady (Football)
Congressman Charlie Crist on Wikimedia
Tom Brady announced his retirement from the NFL in 2022, only to return in 2023. His second stint was filled with personal and professional challenges, but Brady continued to compete at an elite level. His comeback solidified his place as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history.
10. Steve Young (Football)
Presidio of Monterey on Wikimedia
Steve Young’s retirement from football in 1999 was a result of concussions and a long, successful career with the San Francisco 49ers. Despite thinking of a return, Young stayed retired, acknowledging the risks to his health. Young’s decision to retire early set a precedent for players considering their future in the NFL.
11. Joe Montana (Football)
Ronald Reagan Presidential Library & Museum/White House on Wikimedia
Joe Montana retired after leading the San Francisco 49ers to four Super Bowl victories, but his comeback with the Kansas City Chiefs in 1993 was highly anticipated. Although he played well, leading the Chiefs to the playoffs, Montana couldn’t capture another Super Bowl ring. His return wasn’t as glorious, but he left a lasting legacy in the NFL.
12. Rafael Nadal (Tennis)
Alexisrael on Wikimedia
Rafael Nadal’s series of injuries led him to contemplate retirement, but he always returned to the tennis circuit. After missing several major tournaments, Nadal proved his mettle by winning several titles, including the 2017 French Open. His determination to return to form after setbacks has inspired many fans worldwide.
13. Randy Couture (MMA)
U.S. Navy photo on Wikimedia
Randy Couture retired from mixed martial arts multiple times, only to return each time. His comeback at age 47 to fight for the UFC Heavyweight Championship in 2007 was a testament to his willpower. Couture proved that age was not a hindrance, even if his ultimate retirement in 2011 was inevitable.
14. David Beckham (Soccer)
US EMbassy London on Wikimedia
David Beckham’s time at the top of English football ended with a high-profile retirement, but his return to the field in 2013 for Paris Saint-Germain was both symbolic and successful. Beckham helped PSG win the Ligue 1 title in his final season before retiring for good. His return was celebrated globally, proving that Beckham remained a force even in the twilight years of his career.
15. Michael Schumacher (Formula 1)
DPA on Wikimedia
Michael Schumacher’s shock retirement in 2006 was followed by his return to Formula 1 in 2010 with Mercedes. While his comeback didn’t result in the same dominance he had before, Schumacher still displayed flashes of his former brilliance. Unfortunately, injuries in 2013 cut his career short once again.
16. Peyton Manning (Football)
Official U.S. Navy Page on Wikimedia
After neck surgeries that sidelined him for an entire season, Peyton Manning returned to the NFL with the Denver Broncos in 2012. Manning not only made a strong comeback, but he also led the Broncos to a Super Bowl win in 2016. His return was proof that a true champion could rise again.
17. Chris Webber (Basketball)
Ketut Subiyanto on Pexels
After retiring in 2008, Chris Webber made a brief attempt to return to the NBA with the Golden State Warriors in 2012. Unfortunately, Webber’s comeback didn’t last long, as he struggled with injuries and couldn’t recapture his former form. However, his brief return was a testament to his desire to give it one more shot.
18. Barry Sanders (Football)
Emma Bauso on Pexels
Barry Sanders shocked the NFL when he retired from the Detroit Lions at the peak of his career in 1999. Despite speculation, Sanders never made a comeback, leaving fans to wonder what could have been. His retirement remains one of the most mysterious in sports history.
19. Kerry Wood (Baseball)
Pixabay on Pexels
After a standout rookie season in 1998, Kerry Wood faced injury struggles throughout his career. Wood retired in 2012 but briefly returned to pitch for the Chicago Cubs in 2013. Though his comeback didn’t lead to any significant milestones, it allowed fans to appreciate his enduring talent.
20. Mia Hamm (Soccer)
John Mena on Wikimedia
Mia Hamm’s retirement from professional soccer in 2004 ended an era for U.S. women’s soccer. However, she briefly returned to play in charity matches and public events, helping to promote the sport. Her legacy as one of the greatest female soccer players lives on, even though her playing days are over.