8 Most Unique Ice Cream Shops in Wisconsin
Discover Wisconsin’s most unique ice cream shops, where handcrafted flavors, nostalgic parlors, and farm-fresh ingredients create unforgettable sweet experiences.
- Alyana Aguja
- 3 min read
Wisconsin features some of the most distinctive ice cream parlors in the country, combining rich dairy heritage with daring flavors and quaint surroundings. From farm-stead creameries to old-fashioned soda fountains and innovative flavor inventions, every stop provides a singular experience. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional scoops or creative fare such as beer-infused ice cream, these top destinations reveal the sweeter side of the Badger State.
1. Kelley Country Creamery – Fond du Lac
Image from Destination Lake Winnebago Region
Referenced as the “best ice cream in the middle of nowhere,” Kelley Country Creamery is a family business that makes more than 20 flavors fresh each day, with creative twists such as Apple Raisin Strudel and Gingerbread. Customers can view the ice cream process through window cutouts with accompanying countryside views. Don’t overlook their temporary sunflower garden during seasonal periods.
2. Babcock Hall Dairy Store – Madison
Image from Tripadvisor
Located on the University of Wisconsin–Madison campus, this dairy shop serves traditional flavors such as Orange Custard Chocolate Chip, prepared by students in traditional ways. An observation deck lets visitors observe the production process, ranging from milk bottling to cheese making. It’s an authentic taste of Wisconsin dairy tradition.
3. Purple Door Ice Cream – Milwaukee
Image from Purple Door Ice Cream
Dedicated to local ingredients, Purple Door works with local businesses to craft distinctive flavors like Beer and Pretzel and Blackberry Quark. Their seasonal menu guarantees there’s always something new to taste, mirroring Milwaukee’s lively food culture. Stop by their flagship store to treat yourself to these handcrafted treats.
4. Sassy Cow Creamery Store – Columbus
Image from Tripadvisor
Situated between two pastures, this dairy farm is owned by a family and provides fresh, hand-made ice cream produced on the premises. With more than 600 cows grazing in the surrounding area, flavors such as Blueberry Cheesecake and Spotted Cow are as local as possible. Customers can observe the production through viewing windows, having direct contact with the origin of their sweet indulgence.
5. Scoop Deville Ice Cream Shop – Hartford
Image from Tripadvisor
Step back in the 1950s at this quaint parlor, featuring checkered floors, booths, and a functioning jukebox. Famous for its build-your-own sundaes, visitors can top their desserts with one of several flavors, including Red Velvet and Maple Bacon. The retro feel makes it a lovely spot for all ages.
6. The Windmill Ice Cream Shoppe – Tomahawk
Image from Tripadvisor
A neighborhood summer staple, The Windmill features a broad selection of treats, with options for non-dairy too. Guests can come by car, on foot, or by boat to indulge in their homemade maple syrup-topped treats. The quaint location and specialty fare make it a destination stop during summer.
7. The Pearl Ice Cream Parlor & Confectionery – La Crosse
Image from Tripadvisor
This retro 1930s soda fountain offers homemade ice cream, waffle cones, fudge, and a selection of candy specialties. Housed in downtown La Crosse, The Pearl provides an old-fashioned experience through its retro ambiance and traditional offerings. It’s a tasty step back into the past for both children and adults.
8. Cedar Crest Ice Cream Parlor – Manitowoc
Image from Cedar Crest Ice Cream
A landmark attraction, Cedar Crest offers factory-fresh ice cream as well as sundaes, shakes, and malts. With more than 100 flavors, there’s always something new to try. The parlor’s friendly atmosphere makes it a beloved destination for both locals and visitors.