Byron Buxton’s Future Uncertain as Minnesota Twins Weigh Roster Moves

The Minnesota Twins are entering a period of potential transformation following a 70-92 finish in 2025. With Derek Shelton taking over as manager, questions loom about the team’s approach to building a competitive roster. Rumors of major trades have already surfaced, and Buxton—one of the league’s premier outfielders—naturally becomes a focal point in any discussions.

Despite the speculation, the Twins’ leadership emphasizes stability and incremental improvement rather than a full-scale teardown. President of Baseball Operations Derek Falvey has made it clear that his focus remains on enhancing the current roster rather than dismantling it, although the team’s trade deadline activity has left some uncertainty in its wake.

Buxton’s status as a potential trade candidate hinges on these organizational decisions. The two-time All-Star center fielder carries three years and $45 million remaining on his contract, with full no-trade protection through 2026 and the ability to veto trades to up to five clubs in 2027 and 2028.

With Minnesota actively evaluating its pitching rotation and overall roster construction, Buxton’s willingness to consider a trade could be influenced by how the team balances competitiveness with long-term planning.

1. Buxton Open to Playing for Contenders

According to The Athletic’s Dan Hayes, Buxton has expressed a desire to remain with the Twins but is motivated by the chance to compete for a championship. Should Minnesota continue breaking up its roster—potentially moving starting pitchers Joe Ryan or Pablo López—Buxton might reconsider his no-trade protections for select clubs. The 31-year-old outfielder turns 32 next month and has demonstrated both power and consistency, recording 35 home runs and 83 RBIs last season. His performance ensures that he will be highly sought after if he becomes available, giving the Twins leverage to negotiate favorable returns if a trade is considered. Sources indicate that Buxton values winning and may be pragmatic about joining a contending team, rather than holding firm to his no-trade clause in all circumstances. His position highlights the delicate balance between player loyalty and career ambitions, a dynamic increasingly common among MLB veterans with contractual protections. Buxton’s potential movement is tied not only to his contract but also to Minnesota’s broader roster strategy. The organization’s handling of their pitching staff and other core pieces will likely shape his ultimate decision.

2. Front Office Reiterates Commitment to Improvement

Falvey has repeatedly emphasized his commitment to building a better roster without dismantling the team. While the trade deadline saw the departure of 10 players, the front office maintains that the goal is to enhance competitiveness rather than reset entirely. “Adding to this group to make it better remains my stated goal,” Falvey said. “We are focused on ways to improve while staying true to the core of our roster.” He has also maintained open communication with Buxton throughout the offseason, updating him on the team’s plans and reinforcing transparency about the organization’s direction. Meetings between Falvey and Buxton have occurred previously in August and after last season, with further discussions possible as Shelton implements his strategies and fresh ideas within the clubhouse. Maintaining these lines of communication is crucial in retaining high-caliber talent like Buxton while signaling trust and clarity. The challenge for the Twins will be aligning Buxton’s desire to compete with the front office’s vision for sustainable improvement, ensuring both sides remain committed to a cohesive plan.

3. Navigating Buxton’s Contract and Team Needs

Buxton’s sizable contract and no-trade protections add complexity to Minnesota’s offseason planning. With three years and $45 million remaining, any trade scenario would require careful negotiation to balance financial considerations with talent retention. His offensive output and defensive prowess make him a cornerstone player, yet the Twins’ roster needs—particularly in pitching—may compel them to explore options that could include moving a star to address gaps elsewhere. Correlating Buxton’s preferences with organizational priorities will be a delicate process, requiring foresight and strategic timing. The broader implications of handling Buxton’s future extend beyond a single trade. His decisions could influence team morale, fan perception, and the trajectory of Minnesota’s competitive window over the next several seasons. How the Twins navigate Buxton’s situation may serve as a bellwether for their overall approach to roster management, weighing loyalty against the opportunity to acquire critical pieces for sustained success.