Denny Hamlin Calls NASCAR’s Charter Agreement a “Death Certificate” in Courtroom Showdown

Denny Hamlin, a man who seemingly thrives on being NASCAR’s resident anti-hero, took his crusade from the podcast mic to the witness stand this week. The ongoing antitrust trial against NASCAR has been nothing short of a spectacle, and Hamlin, co-owner of 23XI Racing alongside basketball legend Michael Jordan, is playing a starring role.

On the second day of the trial, Hamlin didn’t just testify; he dropped a bombshell, calling NASCAR’s charter proposal a “death certificate” for race teams. You have to admire the drama.

It’s a bold statement, even for a guy who has made a career out of them. But this isn’t just Hamlin stirring the pot on his Actions Detrimental podcast for clicks. This is a federal courtroom, and the stakes are astronomically high.

So, what exactly has gotten Hamlin so fired up that he’s willing to go head-to-head with the racing giant that made him a star? Let’s break down this high-speed legal drama.

1. Why is Hamlin Comparing a NASCAR Charter to a “Death Certificate?”

The core of this mess is the charter system. Introduced in 2016, charters guarantee teams a spot in every Cup Series race and, crucially, a slice of NASCAR’s massive revenue pie, primarily from TV deals. For years, teams have been lobbying for a larger, more permanent piece of that pie. Think of it like being a franchise owner in other major sports leagues. The teams, including Hamlin’s 23XI Racing, want to be treated like permanent partners, not disposable contractors. When the time came to renew the charter agreement in October 2024, most teams fell in line. But Hamlin, alongside Front Row Motorsports, refused to sign what he dramatically dubbed his “death certificate for the future.” Why the morbid metaphor? Because, in his view, signing the agreement would lock his team into an unsustainable business model, leaving them at the mercy of NASCAR’s whims with no long-term security. It was, as he put it in court, “the only decision” he could make. This isn’t just about a few more dollars. It’s about the fundamental structure of the sport. Hamlin and his co-plaintiffs argue that NASCAR operates as a monopoly, using its power to suppress teams and control every aspect of the business, from revenue streams to sponsorships.

2. Hamlin vs. NASCAR: “We Aren’t a Monopoly. You Are.”

The cross-examination was pure courtroom theater. NASCAR’s lawyer, Lawrence E. Buterman, tried to corner Hamlin by comparing NASCAR’s control over teams to Hamlin’s own contracts that prevent drivers from racing for competitors. Hamlin’s response was as blunt as a pit stop tire change: “We aren’t a monopoly. You are.” He argued that drivers have choices—they can sign with different teams. But for teams, there’s only one top-tier stock car racing league in town: NASCAR. Hamlin also pulled back the curtain on his public persona. He admitted that his often-positive commentary about NASCAR on his podcast is a calculated move to avoid retribution. “The reality is, (being) negative affects me in (technical inspection), getting called to the hauler, NASCAR not liking what I said,” he testified. It’s a candid admission that the fear of “lashing” from the sanctioning body is very real, forcing a narrative that “everything is fine” when, clearly, he believes it isn’t.

3. The Fight for the Future of NASCAR

This trial is much bigger than just Denny Hamlin’s bank account. It’s a battle for the soul of NASCAR. For decades, the France family has run the show, and teams have largely had to play by their rules. But with new owners like Michael Jordan and Pitbull entering the sport, the old ways are being challenged. These are individuals who come from leagues like the NBA, where players and team owners have significant power and equity. They look at NASCAR’s model and, frankly, they’re not impressed. Before the trial even began, Hamlin was already on the offensive, blasting an ESPN article as “propaganda” designed to “brainwash” fans. He promised that the “lies are over starting Monday morning. It’s time for the truth. It’s time for change.” Whether he’ll get that change remains to be seen. The trial is expected to last two weeks, and with Michael Jordan himself in the courtroom (yet to testify), you can bet there’s more drama to come. Hamlin has spent 20 years racing in NASCAR; now, he’s racing to redefine it. Signing that “death certificate” was never an option. Instead, he chose to go to war.

• Tags:
• Denny Hamlin