Mariners Prioritize Re-Signing Jorge Polanco Amid Free Agency Push

The Seattle Mariners are entering the offseason with a clear message: they intend to contend. Their recent push in the American League Championship Series fell just short, but the front office has wasted no time making moves to strengthen the roster. Securing Josh Naylor on a five-year contract was the first step, signaling Seattle’s commitment to building around its young core. Now, the organization is turning its attention to Jorge Polanco, whose contributions at shortstop and second base were integral during the playoff run.

Polanco delivered both consistency and timely hitting throughout the season, emerging as one of the Mariners’ quiet leaders. His ability to stabilize the infield and perform under pressure made him invaluable during the postseason, particularly as the team reached a dramatic Game 7 against the Toronto Blue Jays. For Seattle, Polanco represents more than just a complementary piece—he’s a key part of the roster’s identity and a veteran presence the team can rely on in high-leverage situations.

The Mariners’ front office recognizes the rarity of this window. With a young core that showed it can compete in October, keeping core contributors like Polanco preserves chemistry and maintains lineup balance. Losing him would require either a high-risk replacement or an internal solution that may not deliver the same results in critical moments. Polanco’s presence ensures the team maintains the continuity that helped carry them deep into the postseason.

Yet free agency is competitive, and Polanco’s value has not gone unnoticed league-wide. Other teams are likely to pursue him aggressively, knowing he is durable, versatile, and capable of producing in clutch situations. Seattle must weigh the cost of retaining him against the strategic importance of keeping a proven veteran in the infield.

1. Polanco’s Role in the Mariners’ Postseason Push

Jorge Polanco emerged as a dependable figure for Seattle during the 2025 season and playoff run. His performance under pressure reinforced his reputation as a player who can deliver in high-stakes moments. Beyond his offensive contributions, Polanco’s versatility allowed the Mariners to manage defensive matchups effectively, giving manager control over the lineup. His ability to seamlessly switch positions was critical in maintaining infield stability throughout the postseason. Polanco also helped anchor the clubhouse with his veteran presence. Teammates often cited his steady demeanor and leadership as a calming influence during tense playoff games, particularly in late-inning scenarios. For a team that came within one game of its first World Series appearance, Polanco’s combination of skills and leadership made him indispensable. Retaining him is about more than statistics—it’s about preserving the team’s culture and identity as a contender.

2. The Free Agency Landscape and Seattle’s Strategy

Seattle’s pursuit of Polanco comes as free agency heats up and middle-infield talent becomes scarce. Competing clubs recognize his value, which could drive the market and complicate Seattle’s negotiations. Polanco’s durability and postseason track record make him a coveted target for teams looking to solidify their infield and add a reliable bat. The Mariners must be prepared to match or exceed market expectations to secure his services. The front office’s approach suggests a balance of strategy and loyalty. By prioritizing both Naylor and Polanco, Seattle aims to maintain continuity while enhancing its roster for another playoff run. The team’s willingness to invest in proven contributors signals a commitment to October contention. Ultimately, how aggressively the Mariners pursue Polanco will determine whether they maintain the core that nearly reached the World Series. Retaining him could be a defining move for their 2026 championship aspirations.

3. Team Chemistry and Leadership Importance

Polanco’s value extends beyond statistics, serving as a stabilizing presence in the clubhouse. His leadership helped guide Seattle’s young core through the pressures of a deep playoff run. The Mariners are aware that veteran voices are critical in high-stakes games. Polanco’s familiarity with the team’s system and culture reduces risk and ensures smooth communication on the field. Replacing him would require a player who can match both performance and intangibles, a rare combination in free agency. Losing Polanco could disrupt the cohesion that allowed the team to compete at the highest level. By prioritizing his return, Seattle signals that it values leadership and culture as much as raw talent, aiming to preserve the team dynamics that propelled them to the brink of a championship.