Mets Eye Kyle Schwarber to Bolster Lineup After Disappointing 2025

The New York Mets entered the 2025 season with one of baseball’s highest payrolls, spending $341 million on a roster designed to contend. Yet despite the star-studded lineup, including record-breaking free agent Juan Soto, New York fell short, missing the playoffs after a loss to the last-place Miami Marlins. A team built for contention stumbled at the final hurdle, leaving fans and management frustrated.

The offseason brings immediate roster challenges. Several high-salary players are departing, including first baseman Pete Alonso, closer Edwin Diaz, and outfielder Starling Marte. Additionally, the front office elected to part ways with starter Frankie Montas, a free-agent acquisition who failed to meet expectations. These moves open both payroll space and opportunities for strategic reinforcements.

While conventional wisdom might suggest the Mets would scale back spending after another missed postseason, owner Steve Cohen has shown a willingness to double down on talent. The front office, led by president of baseball operations David Stearns, faces a delicate balance of re-signing key players and pursuing new stars to solidify a roster capable of contending in the NL East.

Amid a crowded free-agent market, several players could help fill the gaps. Options on the mound include Framber Valdez, Joe Ryan, and Tarik Skubal, while offensive upgrades could come from Kyle Tucker, Alex Bregman, or a return of Pete Alonso. Yet one player stands out as a potentially transformative addition: designated hitter Kyle Schwarber.

1. Schwarber’s Fit in the Lineup

Much of the Mets’ core is returning next season. Juan Soto anchors the outfield, with middle infielders Francisco Lindor and Marcus Semien holding their positions. Young players from the system are also expected to contribute, but the team lacks a powerful bat to complement its stars. While re-signing Alonso would maintain continuity at first base, Schwarber represents a chance to significantly upgrade the offense. His power and ability to drive in runs could address gaps in the lineup and provide protection for Soto and other key hitters. Currently, Ronny Mauricio is projected as the team’s designated hitter, but his opportunities are limited by the entrenched infield combination of Lindor and Semien. Schwarber, by contrast, would slot naturally into the DH role, giving the Mets a proven bat without disrupting the core infield. Adding Schwarber would allow New York to maximize its offensive potential while maintaining defensive stability. His presence in the middle of the order could transform the team from playoff hopeful to serious contender in the NL East.

2. Free-Agent Strategy and Payroll Considerations

The Mets enter free agency with both challenges and advantages. Departing players free up significant payroll, creating space for marquee acquisitions. Cohen has demonstrated a willingness to spend aggressively to pursue championships, signaling that cost will not necessarily be a limiting factor. Offensive reinforcements remain a priority. While options like Tucker and Bregman offer elite talent, Schwarber’s profile—power hitter, proven postseason contributor, and mid-30s prime—fits New York’s immediate needs. His potential contract, reportedly four years for $160 million, reflects both his ability and the Mets’ financial flexibility. Re-signing Edwin Diaz or Alonso could provide stability, but the team’s strategy appears to favor adding impact players who can immediately enhance the lineup. Schwarber represents a rare opportunity to acquire a high-level bat without sacrificing long-term plans. Additionally, acquiring Schwarber from the Philadelphia Phillies, the team that topped the Mets in the NL East, would be a symbolic victory. Not only does it strengthen New York’s roster, but it simultaneously weakens a divisional rival.

3. Projected Impact and October Outlook

Schwarber’s addition would give the Mets one of the most formidable lineups in the league. With Soto, Lindor, Semien, and a potent DH in Schwarber, New York could address both run production and situational hitting concerns that hampered the team last season. Beyond the statistics, Schwarber brings veteran experience and a presence in the clubhouse that could complement younger players. Integrating him into the lineup would allow the team to develop its young talent while remaining competitive immediately. From a strategic perspective, his presence strengthens the middle of the order, creating protection for Soto and forcing opposing pitchers to navigate multiple threats. This could have a ripple effect on the team’s offensive efficiency and overall performance in tight NL East races. Ultimately, Schwarber’s signing would signal the Mets’ commitment to returning to October contention. With payroll flexibility, strong ownership support, and a clear offensive plan, New York is positioned to compete at the highest level in 2026.