Mets Face Crucial Offseason Decisions as Pete Alonso Hits Free Agency

After reaching the National League Championship Series in 2024, the Mets struggled in 2025, failing to make the playoffs and falling short of expectations. The team now faces significant decisions that could shape its roster and competitive trajectory for the coming seasons.

Pete Alonso, the Mets’ long-time first baseman, is the most pressing question mark. The seven-year veteran spent his entire career in Queens before opting out of his contract at the end of the season to re-enter free agency, joining a crowded market of top-tier MLB free agents.

Alonso’s decision to test the open market has reignited speculation about whether the Mets can retain him. MLB insider Mark Feinsand noted that Alonso is a natural fit in New York’s lineup but acknowledged that if the first baseman seeks a deal longer than four years, he may need to explore opportunities elsewhere.

The Mets now face both internal and external pressures. Internally, they must weigh Alonso’s impact on the team’s core and overall payroll. Externally, they confront competition from several playoff-contending clubs, leaving Alonso’s future in Queens uncertain despite his importance to the franchise.

1. Alonso’s Career and Recent Performance

Alonso has been a cornerstone of the Mets’ lineup since debuting seven years ago. The 2025 season added to his impressive résumé, as he played in all 162 games for the second consecutive year, demonstrating durability and consistency. Statistically, Alonso led the National League with 41 doubles, hit 38 home runs, drove in 126 RBIs, scored 87 runs, and posted a 144 OPS+ alongside 3.4 bWAR. His performance not only anchored the offense but also offered protection for teammates like Juan Soto in the lineup. The first baseman has consistently provided value both at the plate and in the field, making him one of the most reliable and productive players in the league. Replacing Alonso’s contributions would be a significant challenge for the Mets. Alonso’s presence also carries intangible benefits, including leadership and familiarity with the organization’s culture. These qualities add weight to the argument for New York to prioritize re-signing him, provided the financial terms are reasonable.

2. Free Agency Landscape and Competing Teams

Alonso enters the free-agent market with plenty of suitors. Teams such as the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, Philadelphia Phillies, and Baltimore Orioles have all expressed interest, creating a competitive environment for his services. The Mets will need to evaluate their willingness to match market value and contract length while balancing payroll flexibility. Alonso’s previous negotiations with the team, which resulted in a two-year, $54 million extension with an opt-out clause after the first year, set the stage for this current offseason challenge. Other teams may offer longer deals or larger total value, potentially making it difficult for the Mets to retain Alonso. The club will have to consider whether keeping him is worth foregoing other roster moves or opportunities. In addition to contract considerations, the Mets must plan for succession if Alonso departs. Finding a first baseman capable of replicating his production would require either internal development or a costly acquisition, highlighting the stakes involved in the offseason decision.

3. Implications for the Mets’ Future

Alonso’s future with the Mets will significantly influence the team’s competitive window. Keeping him would maintain the core of the lineup, allowing New York to build around his consistency and offensive output. Conversely, losing Alonso would necessitate a strategic pivot. The Mets would need to identify replacement options and possibly restructure their lineup to account for the absence of his bat and leadership. Beyond on-field impact, Alonso’s departure could affect fan engagement and team identity. He has become synonymous with the Mets’ brand and presence in Queens, making his potential exit a notable storyline for the organization. Ultimately, the Mets must balance loyalty, financial prudence, and roster flexibility as they navigate a critical offseason that will define their trajectory for the next several seasons.