'Report facts,' Shilo Sanders disowns Mary Kay Cabot's comments on Shedeur Sanders

The Cleveland Browns haven’t even put on full pads yet, but the drama surrounding their quarterback room is already in midseason form. Colorado safety Shilo Sanders has publicly tormented veteran Browns insider Mary Kay Cabot over a recent report that seemingly relegated his brother, Shedeur Sanders, to a backup role behind Deshaun Watson.

The friction stems from the high-stakes, three-way quarterback competition brewing in Cleveland between Watson, Shedeur Sanders, and Dillon Gabriel.

When a prominent reporter suggested the race was essentially over before it even truly began, the Sanders family took it personally. They transformed a routine offseason minicamp update into a fierce public debate over media bias and journalistic integrity.

The controversy officially erupted on social media after Cabot, a longtime reporter for Cleveland.com, posted on X (formerly Twitter) that Watson had emerged from voluntary minicamp with the “inside track” to win the starting job. She emphatically urged the franchise to declare Watson the undisputed QB1 immediately so the first-team offense could “start to cook.”

1. The Sanders Family Strikes Back

Shilo Sanders was not about to let that commentary slide. Taking to a Twitch livestream, the fiery defensive back took direct aim at Cabot’s reporting style and what he perceives as a lingering bias against his brother. “If you’re gonna be a reporter, be a reporter and report facts,” Shilo said during his broadcast. “Whenever you have your opinion, and your opinion is always something hateful towards Shedeur, then it makes it seem like it’s somethin’ weird. Like, there’s an agenda that you have going on.” Shilo didn’t stop there. He challenged Cabot’s professionalism, comparing her unfavorably to other women in the sports media landscape who “study the game and get the statistics right.”

2. Cabot Responds on the Radio

Mary Kay Cabot, a Bill Nunn Memorial Award winner with decades of experience covering the turbulent Cleveland Browns, was entirely unfazed by the digital onslaught. Appearing on the “92.3 The Fan” radio show in Cleveland shortly after Shilo’s comments went viral, Cabot was asked about the intense criticism from the Sanders camp. Instead of firing back with vitriol, she took the high road, framing the pushback as just another day at the office for a trailblazing female sports journalist. “I really do believe that I have been an inspiration for a lot of women and young girls to know that you can go out there and do a good job in a man’s world and take on all of that that comes with that,” Cabot explained on the air. She noted that she is proud of paving the way for other women in the football world and won’t let emotional outbursts deter her from reporting. Just when it seemed like the feud might naturally fizzle out into the standard NFL offseason ether, Browns offensive coordinator Todd Monken accidentally threw a gallon of gasoline onto the flames. Appearing on the Ken Carman Show, Monken was asked directly about the state of the quarterback room and whether the team was close to crowning a starter. His response sharply contradicted the urgency of Cabot’s initial report. “Would love to [have a starter before training camp],” Monken stated flatly. “But I’m not there yet so I can’t say that. We’ve been on the field three days.” Naturally, the passionate Cleveland fan base seized on Monken’s comments. Social media immediately lit up with Browns fans questioning Cabot’s sources and accusing the media of trying to force the coaching staff’s hand.

3. The Weight of the Quarterback Battle

Deshaun Watson is tethered to one of the most lucrative, fully guaranteed contracts in the history of the sport. The front office desperately needs him to return to his Pro Bowl form to justify the historic investment. On the other hand, Shedeur Sanders brings a level of superstar magnetism and elite arm talent that the franchise simply cannot ignore. He was drafted to be the future, but the timeline for that future is heavily contested. Throw Dillon Gabriel into the mix as a highly accomplished collegiate winner, and the tension in the building is palpable. Every single rep in Berea is being charted, over-analyzed, and debated. For Shedeur Sanders, the challenge is separating the noise from the playbook. He has to prove that his processing speed and accuracy translate seamlessly to the professional level, regardless of what local reporters are tweeting or his brother is streaming. As the dust settles on this early-offseason skirmish, all eyes now turn to the upcoming mandatory minicamps and the grueling slog of training camp in July. The Browns’ coaching staff has made it abundantly clear: there are no coronations happening in May. Watson might have the veteran edge, but Shedeur Sanders is going to get every possible opportunity to rip the starting job away from him. The real truth won’t be found on a Twitch stream or a Twitter timeline; it will be decided under the hot summer sun when the pads finally come on.

• Tags:
• Shilo Sanders
• Mary Kay Cabot