Top 20 NFL Players Who Never Won a Super Bowl
These 20 NFL legends achieved greatness but never captured the sport’s ultimate prize — a Super Bowl ring.
- Chris Graciano
- 4 min read
Some of the greatest talents in NFL history never hoisted the Lombardi Trophy. These superstars missed out on championship glory. This list honors those unforgettable players whose legacies remain powerful, even without a ring.
20. Steve Largent
Darryl Norenberg-Imagn Images
Largent was known for precise routes and steady hands, even without blazing speed. He spent his whole career with the Seahawks, who were never title contenders in his era.
19. Philip Rivers
JAMIE GERMANO/ROCHESTER DEMOCRAT AND CHRONICLE via Imagn Content Services, LLC
Rivers was a fiery competitor with elite numbers but often came up short in January. He spent his prime battling powerhouse AFC rivals. His leadership and grit were never in question.
18. Antonio Gates
Jason Parkhurst-Imagn Images
A favorite of Philip Rivers, Gates scored touchdowns at a historic pace for a tight end. Despite several playoff runs, he never reached the big game.
17. Jason Taylor
RVR Photos-Imagn Images
Taylor’s speed and finesse made him a sack artist throughout the 2000s. He reached a Super Bowl late with Washington but didn’t win.
16. Patrick Willis
Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Willis retired early but left behind a resume full of Pro Bowl nods and jaw-dropping plays. He led San Francisco to a Super Bowl appearance but didn’t win.
15. Andre Johnson
Imagn Images
Johnson was the model of professionalism and production in Houston. Despite putting up elite stats, his teams never made a deep postseason run.
14. Reggie Wayne
Imagn Images
Wayne was a key target for Peyton Manning, making big catches with precision and grace. He won a ring technically in 2006 but was injured and inactive during the Super Bowl game.
13. O.J. Simpson
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
Before his infamous off-field downfall, Simpson was an electrifying rusher. He broke the 2,000-yard barrier in a 14-game season, but team success never followed. His football legacy is complex but undeniably impactful.
12. Warren Moon
Peter Brouillet-Imagn Images
Moon starred in both the CFL and NFL, with a rocket arm and endless poise. Despite Hall of Fame numbers, he never played in a Super Bowl.
11. Fran Tarkenton
Green Bay Press-Gazette / USA TODAY NETWORK
A scrambling pioneer, Tarkenton made three Super Bowl trips with Minnesota but never won. His improvisational style was ahead of its time.
10. Alan Page
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
Page won an MVP as a defensive tackle — almost unheard of. His Vikings teams made four Super Bowl appearances without winning a championship.
9. Calvin Johnson
Christopher Gooley-Imagn Images
“Megatron” was a physical marvel who dominated despite playing on struggling teams. His early retirement shocked fans, but his numbers were off the charts.
8. Junior Seau
RVR Photos-Imagn Images
An emotional leader and tackling machine, Seau defined defensive excellence for years. He reached the Super Bowl late in his career with the Patriots but didn’t win the championship.
7. Jim Kelly
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
Kelly led the Bills to four straight Super Bowls but lost every one. Known for running the “K-Gun” offense, he was a trailblazer at quarterback.
6. Eric Dickerson
Peter Brouillet-Imagn Images
Dickerson set the single-season rushing record and ran with unmatched vision and power. Playoff success didn’t follow his early career explosion.
5. Bruce Smith
Peter Brouillet-Imagn Images
The NFL’s all-time sack leader was a relentless force off the edge. He made four straight Super Bowl appearances with Buffalo but came up short each time.
4. LaDainian Tomlinson
James D. Smith
Tomlinson was a touchdown machine and dual-threat back in his prime. His 2006 MVP season was legendary, but postseason success eluded him.
3. Randy Moss
RVR Photos-Imagn Images
A deep-ball maestro with unmatched athleticism, Moss changed the receiver position. Though he reached the Super Bowl twice, he left empty-handed.
2. Barry Sanders
RVR Photos-Imagn Images
Sanders dazzled with jaw-dropping moves and silent consistency. He retired abruptly at his peak, never having played in a Super Bowl. Still, his talent made him a once-in-a-generation running back.
1. Dan Marino
Malcolm Emmons-Imagn Images
Arguably the best pure passer ever, Marino shattered records with his arm strength and quick release. Despite an MVP and a Super Bowl appearance early in his career, he never made it back.