Yankees Early Favorites in MLB Exec Survey for Kyle Tucker

The pursuit of Kyle Tucker is heating up this MLB offseason, as a new ESPN executive survey positions the New York Yankees as the early favorites for the elite outfielder. The poll, which surveyed 16 MLB executives, highlighted widespread interest across the league, with multiple teams seen as realistic contenders. Tucker’s combination of power, speed, and postseason experience makes him one of the most sought-after free agents.

According to ESPN’s Jesse Rogers, executives were asked both where Tucker might sign and how large a contract he could command. Many anticipate that his deal will be among the biggest in recent MLB history. One executive projected a $350 million, 10-year contract, emphasizing the Yankees’ early positioning as the likely landing spot.

Injury concerns from the second half of the 2025 season may temper the total value. Several executives suggested the final contract could fall short of $400 million, with mid-$300 million projections appearing more realistic given Tucker’s recent health history. Nonetheless, his talent ensures that competition for his services will be intense.

Some executives also expect Tucker to prefer flexibility, possibly opting for a shorter-term structure with opt-outs, allowing him to return to the market after a strong 2026 or 2027 season. The Yankees appear well-suited to accommodate such a deal, reinforcing their position as early favorites.

1. Contract Expectations and Structure

Kyle Tucker’s market value is expected to generate one of the largest contracts of the offseason. Executives predict a deal in the range of $350 million over ten years, with the Yankees emerging as the team most likely to commit to that level of investment. Concerns about Tucker’s second-half injuries in 2025 may limit the ceiling slightly, with some industry insiders suggesting a contract just below $400 million. The balance between guaranteed money and potential opt-outs could allow Tucker to maximize long-term earnings while managing risk. Executives also floated the possibility of a deal similar to Alex Bregman’s recent contracts, featuring a shorter term with a higher annual average value (AAV) and opt-outs to provide flexibility. Such a structure could enable Tucker to re-enter free agency after a strong season and potentially increase his total career earnings. The Yankees are reportedly in a strong position to offer a deal combining size, security, and flexibility, which makes them early favorites in the bidding process.

2. Other Contenders in the Market

While the Yankees lead early, other teams remain active suitors, with the Los Angeles Dodgers viewed as the most significant challenger. Executives note that L.A.’s outfield needs, combined with an aging lineup, make Tucker a natural fit for the team seeking to bolster its offense. The Dodgers’ deep pitching staff is already among MLB’s strongest, and adding Tucker would provide balance and offensive firepower to a team positioned for another championship run. A longer-term contract with a slightly lower AAV and opt-outs could appeal to both Tucker and the Dodgers. Toronto also remains in the mix, though executives emphasized the Yankees and Dodgers as the primary frontrunners. The market for Tucker is expected to stay competitive, with multiple clubs evaluating how best to structure offers. Ultimately, the combination of Tucker’s talent, contract expectations, and team needs ensures that the bidding war will be closely watched and likely set the tone for the MLB offseason.

3. Impact on Team Dynamics

*]:pointer-events-auto scroll-mt-[calc(var(–header-height)+min(200px,max(70px,20svh)))]" dir=“auto” tabindex="-1" data-turn-id=“request-WEB:db7de0ad-72f4-4acd-9f6b-da9eaecbc74c-22” data-testid=“conversation-turn-46” data-scroll-anchor=“true” data-turn=“assistant”>

Adding Kyle Tucker would give the Yankees or Dodgers an immediate boost in their lineup, providing a potent left-handed bat to complement existing stars. His combination of power, speed, and defensive ability makes him a versatile asset capable of contributing in multiple areas. Tucker’s postseason experience adds value in high-pressure situations, giving teams a reliable performer when it matters most. His presence would also allow managers to optimize lineups and matchups, improving overall offensive efficiency and depth.