Yankees Eye Cody Bellinger, Keep Kyle Tucker as Contingency Plan

After an impressive debut season in New York, Cody Bellinger has emerged as a key target for the Yankees’ long-term plans. The franchise is actively pursuing a deal to retain him, recognizing his familiarity with the team and proven impact at the plate.

However, Bellinger’s free-agent market is competitive, with several teams likely to offer compelling contracts. The Yankees are aware that a better offer could lure him away, and they are preparing contingencies to safeguard their roster.

One such contingency is Kyle Tucker, whom the Yankees have identified as a preferred backup target should negotiations with Bellinger stall. Tucker’s talent and versatility make him an attractive option, providing an insurance plan without lowering expectations for offensive production.

With these possibilities in play, the Yankees are navigating a critical offseason. How they manage Bellinger’s potential departure and Tucker’s pursuit could shape their lineup for years to come.

1. The Pursuit of Bellinger

Bellinger’s first season in the Bronx showcased his ability to contribute both power and consistency. His combination of home run potential, on-base skills, and defensive versatility makes him a central piece for New York’s plans. The Yankees’ familiarity with Bellinger could give them an edge in negotiations. Having already integrated him into the clubhouse and lineup, the team understands his fit within their system better than most suitors. Despite this advantage, Bellinger’s market is robust. Several teams with payroll flexibility may offer lucrative deals, forcing the Yankees to balance competitive bids with long-term roster strategy. Ultimately, retaining Bellinger would provide continuity and maintain the core of the lineup, but the Yankees are preparing for scenarios where this may not be feasible.

2. Kyle Tucker as a Strategic Alternative

Kyle Tucker has emerged as the Yankees’ preferred contingency if Bellinger departs. The outfielder spent 2025 with the Chicago Cubs, hitting .266 with 22 home runs, 73 RBIs, and 25 stolen bases, continuing a streak of All-Star appearances. Tucker’s career stats reflect consistent production: a .273 batting average, 147 home runs, 490 RBIs, and 119 stolen bases over eight MLB seasons. His combination of power, speed, and experience would make him an immediate contributor in New York. The transition would require Tucker to shift from right to left field, as Aaron Judge occupies the latter position. The Yankees’ confidence in his defensive adaptability suggests they believe the move is manageable and that Tucker could thrive in their system. Adding Tucker would bolster the lineup significantly, offsetting the loss of Bellinger and ensuring New York remains competitive in both the AL East and on a broader national stage.

3. Implications for the Yankees’ Offseason

The Yankees are entering one of the most intriguing offseasons in recent memory. Retaining Bellinger would solidify the roster, while a potential deal for Tucker offers a high-quality alternative without sacrificing offensive firepower. The organization’s dual-track approach demonstrates flexibility and strategic planning, keeping options open while preparing for unpredictable free-agent dynamics. Tucker’s acquisition would also signal to fans and competitors that the Yankees are committed to maintaining elite talent, regardless of player departures. His presence could offset any gaps in power or speed, maintaining the team’s competitive balance. As negotiations unfold, the Yankees’ offseason decisions could set the tone for the next several seasons, determining not only roster composition but also future financial flexibility and team chemistry.